Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Utah Health, Salt Lake City, UT, United States.
Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Women's Health, University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, MN, United States.
JMIR Med Educ. 2024 Oct 21;10:e48518. doi: 10.2196/48518.
As part of the residency application process in the United States, many medical specialties now offer applicants the opportunity to send program signals that indicate high interest to a limited number of residency programs. To determine which residency programs to apply to, and which programs to send signals to, applicants need accurate information to determine which programs align with their future training goals. Most applicants use a program's website to review program characteristics and criteria, so describing the current state of residency program websites can inform programs of best practices.
This study aims to characterize information available on obstetrics and gynecology residency program websites and to determine whether there are differences in information available between different types of residency programs.
This was a cross-sectional observational study of all US obstetrics and gynecology residency program website content. The authorship group identified factors that would be useful for residency applicants around program demographics and learner trajectories; application criteria including standardized testing metrics, residency statistics, and benefits; and diversity, equity, and inclusion mission statements and values. Two authors examined all available websites from November 2011 through March 2022. Data analysis consisted of descriptive statistics and one-way ANOVA, with P<.05 considered significant.
Among 290 programs, 283 (97.6%) had websites; 238 (82.1%) listed medical schools of current residents; 158 (54.5%) described residency alumni trajectories; 107 (36.9%) included guidance related to the preferred United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 scores; 53 (18.3%) included guidance related to the Comprehensive Osteopathic Medical Licensing Examination Level 1 scores; 185 (63.8%) included international applicant guidance; 132 (45.5%) included a program-specific mission statement; 84 (29%) included a diversity, equity, and inclusion statement; and 167 (57.6%) included program-specific media or links to program social media on their websites. University-based programs were more likely to include a variety of information compared to community-based university-affiliated and community-based programs, including medical schools of current residents (113/123, 91.9%, university-based; 85/111, 76.6%, community-based university-affiliated; 40/56, 71.4%, community-based; P<.001); alumni trajectories (90/123, 73.2%, university-based; 51/111, 45.9%, community-based university-affiliated; 17/56, 30.4%, community-based; P<.001); the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step 1 score guidance (58/123, 47.2%, university-based; 36/111, 32.4%, community-based university-affiliated; 13/56, 23.2%, community-based; P=.004); and diversity, equity, and inclusion statements (57/123, 46.3%, university-based; 19/111, 17.1%, community-based university-affiliated; 8/56, 14.3%, community-based; P<.001).
There are opportunities to improve the quantity and quality of data on residency websites. From this work, we propose best practices for what information should be included on residency websites that will enable applicants to make informed decisions.
作为美国住院医师申请流程的一部分,许多医学专业现在为申请人提供向数量有限的住院医师项目发送项目信号的机会,以表明他们对项目的高度兴趣。为了确定要申请哪些住院医师项目以及向哪些项目发送信号,申请人需要准确的信息来确定哪些项目与他们未来的培训目标相符。大多数申请人使用项目的网站来审查项目的特点和标准,因此描述住院医师项目网站的现状可以使项目了解最佳实践。
本研究旨在描述妇产科住院医师项目网站上提供的信息,并确定不同类型的住院医师项目之间在可用信息方面是否存在差异。
这是一项对所有美国妇产科住院医师项目网站内容的横断面观察性研究。作者小组确定了与项目人口统计学和学习者轨迹、申请标准(包括标准化考试指标、住院医师统计数据和福利)以及多样性、公平性和包容性使命陈述和价值观相关的对住院医师申请人有用的因素。两名作者于 2011 年 11 月至 2022 年 3 月期间检查了所有可用的网站。数据分析包括描述性统计和单因素方差分析,P<.05 被认为具有统计学意义。
在 290 个项目中,有 283 个(97.6%)有网站;238 个(82.1%)列出了当前住院医师的医学院;158 个(54.5%)描述了住院医师校友的轨迹;107 个(36.9%)包括了与首选美国医师执照考试第 1 步分数相关的指导;53 个(18.3%)包括了与全面骨科医师执照考试第 1 步分数相关的指导;185 个(63.8%)包括了国际申请人指导;132 个(45.5%)包括了项目特定的使命陈述;84 个(29%)包括了多样性、公平性和包容性声明;167 个(57.6%)在其网站上包括了特定于项目的媒体或链接到项目社交媒体。与社区大学附属和社区医院的项目相比,大学附属的项目更有可能包括各种信息,包括当前住院医师的医学院(113/123,91.9%,大学附属;85/111,76.6%,社区大学附属;40/56,71.4%,社区医院;P<.001);校友轨迹(90/123,73.2%,大学附属;51/111,45.9%,社区大学附属;17/56,30.4%,社区医院;P<.001);美国医师执照考试第 1 步分数指导(58/123,47.2%,大学附属;36/111,32.4%,社区大学附属;13/56,23.2%,社区医院;P=.004);以及多样性、公平性和包容性声明(57/123,46.3%,大学附属;19/111,17.1%,社区大学附属;8/56,14.3%,社区医院;P<.001)。
有机会提高住院医师网站上数据的数量和质量。从这项工作中,我们提出了关于住院医师网站应该包含哪些信息的最佳实践,这些信息将使申请人能够做出明智的决策。