Department of Clinical Immunology, PathWest Laboratory Medicine WA, Fiona Stanley Hospital, Perth, Australia.
School of Biomedical Sciences, the University of Western Australia, Perth, Australia.
HLA. 2024 Oct;104(4):e15725. doi: 10.1111/tan.15725.
The advent of third-generation sequencing (TGS) represents a significant shift in the field of genetic sequencing, enabling single-molecule sequencing to overcome limitations of short-read NGS platforms. Several studies have assessed the utilisation of TGS in HLA genotyping, though many of these studies have described the high error rate as an obstacle to achieving a robust and highly accurate HLA typing assay. In 2021, Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT) released the high-accuracy sequencing Kit 14 and the MinION flow cell model R10.4.1, which were reported to achieve sequencing accuracies up to 99%. The aim of this study was to validate this novel high-accuracy sequencing kit for HLA genotyping coupled with a full-gene HLA PCR assay. Comparison with historical data obtained using legacy flow cell models such as R9.4, R10.3 and R10.4 was also done to assess progressive improvement in sequencing performance with each sequential release. The workflow was validated based on data throughput, sequence quality and accuracy, and HLA genotyping resolution. An initial validation was performed using an internal reference panel of 42 samples representing common HLA allele groups, followed by an analysis of data obtained from 111 sequencing batch runs since the implementation, to assess assay performance and define quality control metrics to assess inter-run variability and monitor quality. Furthermore, challenges arising from MinION flow cell stability and use, and assessment of barcode contamination are discussed. The findings of this study highlight advantages of ONT sequencing kit 14/R10.4.1 for HLA genotyping and the implementation considerations for the routine diagnostic HLA laboratory.
第三代测序(TGS)的出现代表了遗传测序领域的重大转变,使单分子测序能够克服短读长 NGS 平台的局限性。已有多项研究评估了 TGS 在 HLA 基因分型中的应用,但其中许多研究都描述了高错误率是实现稳健且高度准确 HLA 分型检测的障碍。2021 年,牛津纳米孔技术公司(ONT)发布了高准确度测序试剂盒 14 和 MinION 流动池模型 R10.4.1,据称其测序准确度高达 99%。本研究旨在验证该新型高准确度测序试剂盒与全基因 HLA PCR 检测法相结合用于 HLA 基因分型的性能。还与 R9.4、R10.3 和 R10.4 等传统流动池模型获得的历史数据进行了比较,以评估随着每个连续版本的发布测序性能的逐步提高。该工作流程是基于数据通量、序列质量和准确性以及 HLA 基因分型分辨率进行验证的。首先使用代表常见 HLA 等位基因组的 42 个样本的内部参考面板进行初始验证,然后分析自实施以来的 111 个测序批次运行的数据,以评估检测性能并定义质量控制指标以评估批间变异性并监测质量。此外,还讨论了 MinION 流动池稳定性和使用带来的挑战,以及条形码污染的评估。本研究的结果强调了 ONT 测序试剂盒 14/R10.4.1 用于 HLA 基因分型的优势,以及在常规诊断 HLA 实验室中实施的考虑因素。