Jordan Matthew, Vafidis Jim, Steer Mark, Fawcett Kathy, Meakin Kathy, Parry Gareth, Brown Matthew
University of the West of England Bristol UK.
Eco-Explore Mountain Ash UK.
Ecol Evol. 2024 Oct 22;14(10):e70463. doi: 10.1002/ece3.70463. eCollection 2024 Oct.
Measuring the outcome of practical interventions and actions helps to inform conservation management objectives and assess progress towards objectives and targets. Measuring success also informs future management by identifying actions that are effective and those that are not. Scrub vegetation is an important habitat type in terrestrial ecosystems, providing important shelter and food resources for biodiversity and livestock. Much of practical land management in the UK involves the monitoring and management of scrub, and current drone-based methods of scrub collection requires expensive equipment or complex methods. A 2021 paper determined a cheap and simple way to determine scrub levels, and this could potentially be used to map temporal changes, as well as identify directional change in scrub. This study looks at whether the method outlined in the 2021 study could be used to measure temporal and directional changes in scrub cover on two nature reserves in the UK: Daneway Banks in Gloucestershire and Flat Holm Island in the Severn Estuary. Scrub levels at Daneway Banks increased from 14.63% in 2015 to 16.52% in 2017, before decreasing to 14.89% in 2021 due to managed cutting and clearing. Scrub cover at Flatholm Island decreased from 10.18% in 2019 to 8.71% in 2021. The exact locations of scrub growth and loss for each site was also calculated and mapped. This approach was found to be a viable way of measuring temporal and directional change in scrub levels. The data can also be used to reframe changes in scrub levels as a shift towards vegetation succession or reduction, to better visualise how changes in scrub levels affect overall site management goals, and is a cheaper, more accessible alternative to current methods of measuring temporal vegetation changes.
衡量实际干预措施和行动的成果有助于明确保护管理目标,并评估在实现目标和指标方面取得的进展。衡量成功与否还能通过识别有效和无效的行动,为未来的管理提供参考。灌丛植被是陆地生态系统中的一种重要栖息地类型,为生物多样性和牲畜提供重要的庇护所和食物资源。英国的许多实际土地管理工作都涉及灌丛的监测和管理,而目前基于无人机的灌丛数据采集方法需要昂贵的设备或复杂的操作。2021年的一篇论文确定了一种廉价且简单的方法来测定灌丛水平,该方法有可能用于绘制时间变化图,以及识别灌丛的方向性变化。本研究探讨了2021年研究中概述的方法是否可用于测量英国两个自然保护区——格洛斯特郡的丹威河岸和塞文河口的弗拉特霍姆岛——灌丛覆盖的时间和方向性变化。丹威河岸的灌丛水平从2015年的14.63%增加到2017年的16.52%,之后由于进行了人工砍伐和清理,到2021年降至14.89%。弗拉特霍姆岛的灌丛覆盖从2019年的10.18%降至2021年的8.71%。还计算并绘制了每个地点灌丛生长和减少的确切位置。结果发现,这种方法是测量灌丛水平时间和方向性变化的一种可行方式。这些数据还可用于将灌丛水平的变化重新表述为向植被演替或退化的转变,以便更好地直观展示灌丛水平变化如何影响整体场地管理目标,并且它是一种比当前测量植被时间变化方法更便宜、更易获取的替代方法。