Tian Jiahe, Lam Tiffany G, Ross Sophie K, Ciener Benjamin, Leskinen Sandra, Sivakumar Sharanya, Bennett David A, Menon Vilas, McKhann Guy M, Runnels Alexi, Teich Andrew F
Department of Pathology and Cell Biology, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, USA.
Taub Institute for Research on Alzheimer's Disease and the Aging Brain, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, USA.
bioRxiv. 2024 Oct 17:2024.10.14.618253. doi: 10.1101/2024.10.14.618253.
Human brain tissue studies have historically used a range of metrics to assess RNA quality. However, few large-scale cross-comparisons of pre-sequencing quality metrics with RNA-seq quality have been published. Here, we analyze how well metrics gathered before RNA sequencing (post-mortem interval (PMI) and RNA integrity number RIN) relate to analyses of RNA quality after sequencing (Percent of counts in Top Ten genes (PTT), 5' bias, and 3' bias) as well as with individual gene counts across the transcriptome. We conduct this analysis across four different human cortical brain tissue collections sequenced with varying library preparation protocols. PMI and RIN have a low inverse correlation, and both PMI and RIN show consistent and opposing correlations with PTT. Unlike PMI, RIN shows strong consistent correlations with measurements of 3' and 5' bias, and RIN also correlates with 3,933 genes across datasets, in comparison to 138 genes for PMI. Neuronal and immune response genes correlate positively and negatively with RIN respectively, suggesting that different gene sets have divergent relationships with RIN in brain tissue. In summary, these analyses suggest that conventional metrics of RNA quality have varying degrees of value, and that PMI has an overall minimal but reproducible effect on RNA quality.
历史上,人类脑组织研究使用了一系列指标来评估RNA质量。然而,很少有关于测序前质量指标与RNA测序质量的大规模交叉比较被发表。在这里,我们分析了RNA测序前收集的指标(死后间隔时间(PMI)和RNA完整性数值(RIN))与测序后RNA质量分析(前十基因计数百分比(PTT)、5'偏向和3'偏向)以及转录组中单个基因计数之间的关联程度。我们对四个不同的人类大脑皮质组织样本集进行了此项分析,这些样本集采用了不同的文库制备方案进行测序。PMI和RIN呈低度负相关,并且PMI和RIN与PTT均呈现出一致且相反的相关性。与PMI不同,RIN与3'和5'偏向的测量结果呈现出强烈的一致相关性,并且RIN在各数据集中还与3933个基因相关,相比之下,PMI仅与138个基因相关。神经元和免疫反应基因分别与RIN呈正相关和负相关,这表明在脑组织中不同的基因集与RIN具有不同的关系。总之,这些分析表明,传统的RNA质量指标具有不同程度的价值,并且PMI对RNA质量的总体影响最小但具有可重复性。