Skelton Salem, Riggs Damien W
College of Education, Psychology and Social Work, Flinders University, Adelaide, South Australia, Australia.
Int J Transgend Health. 2024 Feb 9;25(4):868-877. doi: 10.1080/26895269.2024.2310543. eCollection 2024.
A growing body of research has explored the benefits of animal companionship to trans people, yet too often this research reinforces human exceptionalism, and fails to explore what it means for trans people to engage in more-than-human relationships. Conversely, trans theorists have increasingly turned to consider what it means for trans people to lay claim to the category 'human', wrapped up as it is in normative claims to gender and sociality.
This paper aims to investigate how trans people make sense of their relationships with non-human animals, so as to provide a critique of the binaries of animal/human and nature/culture.
27 binary trans or non-binary people living in Australia were interviewed about their experiences with family, with a specific probe question focused on animal companions. Thematic analysis was used to explore experiences of the more-than-human among the participants.
Three themes were developed: (1) Animals as facilitators of connections to the 'natural world', (2) Coming to understand animal ways of being, and (3) Challenging norms of animal ownership.
The paper concludes by calling for ongoing theorization about more-than-human relationships as experienced by trans people and their animal companions. Specifically, there is a pressing need to think through what it means to claim the category 'human' when it is so often premised upon exclusion.
越来越多的研究探讨了动物陪伴对跨性别者的益处,但这类研究常常强化人类例外论,未能探究跨性别者建立超越人类关系意味着什么。相反,跨性别理论学家越来越多地转向思考跨性别者宣称自己属于“人类”这一类别意味着什么,因为这一类别与性别和社会性的规范主张紧密相连。
本文旨在调查跨性别者如何理解他们与非人类动物的关系,从而对动物/人类以及自然/文化的二元对立进行批判。
对居住在澳大利亚的27名二元性别跨性别者或非二元性别者进行了访谈,询问他们与家人的经历,并特别设置了一个关于动物陪伴的探究问题。采用主题分析法来探索参与者中超越人类的经历。
形成了三个主题:(1)动物作为连接“自然世界”的促进者,(2)开始理解动物的生存方式,(3)挑战动物所有权规范。
本文呼吁持续对跨性别者及其动物伴侣所经历的超越人类关系进行理论化。具体而言,迫切需要思考在“人类”类别常常以排斥为前提的情况下宣称自己属于这一类别意味着什么。