Grace P A, Pitt H A, Tompkins R K, DenBesten L, Longmire W P
Am J Surg. 1986 Jan;151(1):141-9. doi: 10.1016/0002-9610(86)90024-3.
In two 5 year periods (1975 to 1979 and 1980 to 1984), 96 patients underwent pancreatoduodenal resection, which included 74 partial pancreatic resections and 22 total pancreatectomies. Thirty-seven of these patients had resections with preservation of the pylorus. Substantial reductions in perioperative mortality (2 percent versus 10 percent) and morbidity (26 percent versus 49 percent) (p less than 0.05) were achieved in the latter period. Pylorus preservation, with a mortality and morbidity of 3 percent and 27 percent, respectively, did not increase operative risk or compromise long-term survival in patients with malignant disease. In comparison, relatively high mortality and morbidity rates (14 percent and 59 percent) accompanied total pancreatectomy without improved long-term survival. Five year actuarial survival for nonpancreatic periampullary adenocarcinomas was 58 percent. Thus, we recommend pancreatoduodenectomy with preservation of the pylorus for resection of periampullary tumors. These patients, whose only possibility for cure is a major pancreatic resection, should not be denied this opportunity on the basis of reports from a previous era.
在两个5年期间(1975年至1979年和1980年至1984年),96例患者接受了胰十二指肠切除术,其中包括74例部分胰腺切除术和22例全胰切除术。这些患者中有37例行保留幽门的切除术。后期围手术期死亡率(2%对10%)和发病率(26%对49%)(p<0.05)大幅降低。保留幽门的患者死亡率和发病率分别为3%和27%,并未增加手术风险或影响恶性疾病患者的长期生存。相比之下,全胰切除术伴随着相对较高的死亡率和发病率(14%和59%),且长期生存并未改善。非胰腺壶腹周围腺癌的5年精算生存率为58%。因此,我们建议对壶腹周围肿瘤行保留幽门的胰十二指肠切除术。这些患者唯一的治愈可能性是进行大型胰腺切除术,不应基于过去时代的报告而剥夺他们的这个机会。