Kreis Barbara K, Groß Julia, Pachur Thorsten
Department of Psychology, University of Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany.
School of Management, Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany.
Psychon Bull Rev. 2025 Jun;32(3):1217-1230. doi: 10.3758/s13423-024-02575-4. Epub 2024 Oct 28.
Accurately estimating and assessing real-world quantities (e.g., how long it will take to get to the train station; the calorie content of a meal) is a central skill for adaptive cognition. To date, theoretical and empirical work on the mental resources recruited by real-world estimation has focused primarily on the role of domain knowledge (e.g., knowledge of the metric and distributional properties of objects in a domain). Here we examined the role of basic numeric abilities - specifically, symbolic-number mapping - in real-world estimation. In Experiment 1 ( ) and Experiment 2 ( ), participants first completed a country-population estimation task (a task domain commonly used to study real-world estimation) and then completed a number-line task (an approach commonly used to measure symbolic-number mapping). In both experiments, participants with better performance in the number-line task made more accurate estimates in the estimation task. Moreover, Experiment 2 showed that performance in the number-line task predicts estimation accuracy independently of domain knowledge. Further, in Experiment 2 the association between estimation accuracy and symbolic-number mapping did not depend on whether the number-line task involved small numbers (up to 1000) or large numbers that matched the range of the numbers in the estimation task (up to 100,000,000). Our results show for the first time that basic numeric abilities contribute to the estimation of real-world quantities. We discuss implications for theories of real-world estimation and for interventions aiming to improve people's ability to estimate real-world quantities.
准确估计和评估现实世界中的数量(例如,到达火车站需要多长时间;一顿饭的卡路里含量)是适应性认知的一项核心技能。迄今为止,关于现实世界估计所调用的心理资源的理论和实证研究主要集中在领域知识的作用上(例如,对某一领域中物体的度量和分布属性的了解)。在这里,我们研究了基本数字能力——具体来说,符号数字映射——在现实世界估计中的作用。在实验1( )和实验2( )中,参与者首先完成一项国家人口估计任务(一个常用于研究现实世界估计的任务领域),然后完成一项数字线任务(一种常用于测量符号数字映射的方法)。在这两个实验中,在数字线任务中表现更好的参与者在估计任务中做出了更准确的估计。此外,实验2表明,数字线任务的表现独立于领域知识预测估计准确性。此外,在实验2中,估计准确性与符号数字映射之间的关联并不取决于数字线任务涉及的是小数字(高达1000)还是与估计任务中的数字范围相匹配的大数字(高达1亿)。我们的结果首次表明,基本数字能力有助于对现实世界数量的估计。我们讨论了对现实世界估计理论以及旨在提高人们估计现实世界数量能力的干预措施的影响。