Specific analysis of SOD1 enzymatic activity in CSF from ALS patients with and without SOD1 mutations.

Mutations in superoxide dismutase-1 (SOD1) are a cause of hereditary amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) through a gain-of-function mechanism involving unfolded mutant SOD1. Intrathecal gene therapy using the antisense-oligo-nucleotide drug tofersen to reduce SOD1 expression delays disease progression and has recently been approved in the United States and the European Union. However, the discovery of children homozygous for inactivating SOD1 mutations developing the SOD1 Deficiency Syndrome (ISODDES) with injury to the motor system suggests that a too low SOD1 antioxidant activity may be deleterious in humans. Measuring SOD1 activity in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in tofersen-treated patients is recommended but difficult due to low concentration and the presence of the isoenzyme SOD3. We here present a sensitive method to assess SOD1 activity by removing SOD3 from CSF samples using highly specific immobilized antibodies and subsequent measurement of the SOD activity. We validated the method on 171 CSF samples from ALS patients with and without mutations and controls and used paired erythrocyte samples for comparison. We found that in ALS patients with wildtype SOD1, the SOD1 activity in CSF was equal to controls, but patients with mutant SOD1 show lower activity in CSF, even for patients with mutants previously reported to have full activity in erythrocytes. Activity variation in CSF was large among patients carrying the same SOD1 mutation and larger than in erythrocytes and in post-mortem nervous tissue. Additionally, we identified a discrepancy between the SOD1 activity and protein level measured with ELISA in both CSF and erythrocytes. Since antibodies used for SOD1 ELISA-quantification are raised against the natively folded wildtype SOD1, the concentration of mutant SOD1s may be underestimated. Analysis of SOD1 enzymatic activity in CSF is therefore a more reliable way to monitor the effect of SOD1-lowering drugs.