Université Clermont Auvergne, INRAE, VetAgro Sup, UMR Herbivores, 63122 Saint-Genès-Champanelle, France; Animal Production Department, Faculty of Agriculture, Cairo University, Giza,Egypt.
Université Clermont Auvergne, INRAE, VetAgro Sup, UMR Herbivores, 63122 Saint-Genès-Champanelle, France.
Animal. 2024 Nov;18(11):101354. doi: 10.1016/j.animal.2024.101354. Epub 2024 Oct 10.
Identification of plasma biomarkers for feed efficiency in growing beef cattle offers a promising opportunity for developing prediction models to improve precision feeding strategies. However, these models must accurately predict feed efficiency at early stages of fattening. Our study aimed to evaluate the reliability of candidate biomarkers previously identified in late-fattening cattle when analysed during early fattening stages and to develop diet-specific prediction equations for residual feed intake (RFI). From a total of 364 Charolais bulls across seven cohorts, we selected 64 animals with extreme RFI values. The animals were fed either a corn‑ or grass-silage diets. These animals were chosen from four out of the available seven cohorts. Animals from three cohorts (24 high-RFI and 24 low-RFI, having a mean RFI difference of 1.48 kg/d) were used for biomarker confirmation and prediction model training. Animals from a fourth cohort (8 high-RFI and 8 low-RFI, having a mean RFI difference of 0.98 kg/d) were used for model external validation. Blood samples were collected at the beginning of the feed efficiency test (333 ± 20 days), and plasma underwent targeted metabolomic for 630 metabolites, natural abundance of N (δN), insulin, and IGF-1 analysis. Seven previously identified plasma biomarkers for RFI in late-fattening beef cattle still kept their capability for discriminating low and high RFI animals when analysed during early fattening stages (P < 0.05). Among these confirmed biomarkers, five were common for both grass- and corn-fed animals (creatinine, β-alanine, triglyceride TG18:0_34:2, symmetric dimethyl-arginine and phosphatidylcholine PC aa C30:2) while two were diet-specific (IGF-1 for grass silage-based diet, and isoleucine for corn silage-based diet. No new plasma biomarkers of RFI were identified at early-fattening stages (false discovery rate > 0.05). Prediction models were developed based on seven confirmed RFI biomarkers analysed during early-fattening. Two logistic regression models incorporating creatinine and either IGF-1 (for grass silage-based diet) or PC aa C30:2 (for corn silage-based diet) effectively distinguished between high- and low-RFI animals with high sensitivity and specificity (area under the curve > 0.80). The biomarkers used in the models showed moderate to high repeatability between early and late fattening stages (0.45 < r < 0.65). The models were successfully externally validated, with more than 85% of animals from the fourth cohort correctly classified. Once validated in larger cohorts and utilising cost-effective and rapid analytical methods, these models could support precision feeding and breeding programmes, aiming to reduce the cost of raising beef cattle.
在生长肉牛中鉴定用于饲料效率的血浆生物标志物为开发预测模型提供了一个有前途的机会,以改善精准饲养策略。然而,这些模型必须在育肥的早期阶段准确预测饲料效率。我们的研究旨在评估在育肥后期鉴定出的候选生物标志物在育肥早期阶段分析时的可靠性,并为剩余采食量 (RFI) 开发特定于饮食的预测方程。在七个队列的 364 头夏洛来公牛中,我们选择了 64 头具有极端 RFI 值的动物。这些动物分别喂食玉米或草青贮饲料。这些动物来自四个队列中的四个。来自三个队列的动物(24 头高 RFI 和 24 头低 RFI,平均 RFI 差异为 1.48 kg/d)用于生物标志物确认和预测模型训练。来自第四个队列的动物(8 头高 RFI 和 8 头低 RFI,平均 RFI 差异为 0.98 kg/d)用于模型外部验证。在饲料效率测试开始时(333 ± 20 天)采集血液样本,对血浆进行靶向代谢组学分析,检测 630 种代谢物、天然丰度 N(δN)、胰岛素和 IGF-1。在育肥后期鉴定出的 7 种用于 RFI 的血浆生物标志物在育肥早期阶段分析时仍然能够区分低 RFI 和高 RFI 动物(P < 0.05)。在这些确认的生物标志物中,有 5 种在草和玉米饲养的动物中是共同的(肌酸酐、β-丙氨酸、甘油三酯 TG18:0_34:2、对称二甲基精氨酸和磷脂酰胆碱 PC aa C30:2),而 2 种是饮食特异性的(IGF-1 用于草青贮饲料,异亮氨酸用于玉米青贮饲料。在育肥早期阶段没有发现新的 RFI 血浆生物标志物(错误发现率 > 0.05)。基于在育肥早期阶段分析的 7 种确认的 RFI 生物标志物,开发了预测模型。两个逻辑回归模型,分别纳入肌酸酐和 IGF-1(用于草青贮饲料)或 PC aa C30:2(用于玉米青贮饲料),能够有效地将高 RFI 和低 RFI 动物区分开来,具有较高的灵敏度和特异性(曲线下面积 > 0.80)。在早期和晚期育肥阶段,用于模型的生物标志物具有中等至高度的可重复性(0.45 < r < 0.65)。这些模型成功地进行了外部验证,第四队列中超过 85%的动物被正确分类。一旦在更大的队列中得到验证,并利用经济高效且快速的分析方法,这些模型可以支持精准饲养和育种计划,旨在降低饲养肉牛的成本。