Department of Pediatrics, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Division of Immunology, Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Nov 5;24(1):1267. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-06158-8.
We aimed to examine medical students' perceptions regarding their professional identity and explore their creative narratives utilizing the Dialogical-Self Theory (DST).
This is a mixed-method study. First-year medical students at Tehran University of Medical Sciences (TUMS, Tehran, Iran wrote a creative narrative about their perspectives on their future profession. Based on DST, qualitative-directed content analysis and summative approach were used to identify and quantify different "I-positions" to assess professional identity formation.
One hundred eighty-eight first-year medical students at TUMS participated in the study in 2021-2022. In the creative narratives, the reference to "I" was more than other pronouns (he/she/they). The use of "I" positively correlated with rank in the university entrance exam (P value = 0.03). The highest application of "I" per participant belonged to the "present I-position," and the lowest to the "promoter," which has the highest rank in the formation of professional identity. Women tended to use the "present I-position" more than men (P value = 0.03).
First-year medical students have accepted their self-role in forming professional identity; however, they have not found a vast perspective of it, as shown by their inability to use meta I-position and promoter I-position. Therefore, educators must provide plans within the curriculum to enhance competencies of professional identity formation. These plans can include incorporating narration writing to encourage medical students to reflect on their professional identity.
我们旨在通过对话自我理论(DST)来考察医学生对其专业身份的看法,并探索他们的创造性叙述。
这是一项混合方法研究。德黑兰医科大学(TUMS,伊朗德黑兰)的一年级医学生首先撰写了一篇关于他们对未来职业看法的创造性叙述。基于 DST,采用定性导向的内容分析和总结方法来识别和量化不同的“我-立场”,以评估专业身份的形成。
2021 年至 2022 年,TUMS 的 188 名一年级医学生参加了这项研究。在创造性叙述中,提到“我”的次数多于其他代词(他/她/他们)。“我”的使用与大学入学考试成绩呈正相关(P 值=0.03)。每个参与者的“我”的使用量与“当前我立场”最高,与“推动者”最低,而“推动者”在专业身份形成中的地位最高。女性比男性更倾向于使用“当前我立场”(P 值=0.03)。
一年级医学生已经接受了自己在形成专业身份中的角色;然而,他们并没有找到广泛的视角,这表明他们无法使用元我立场和推动者我立场。因此,教育者必须在课程中制定计划,以增强专业身份形成的能力。这些计划可以包括纳入叙述写作,以鼓励医学生反思自己的专业身份。