Murthy Vishal D, Le Lena, Heater Haley D, Guess Sarah C, Chen Annie V
Department of Surgical and Radiological Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of California, Davis, CA, USA.
Social and Economic Sciences Research Center, Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164, USA.
J Vet Med Educ. 2024 Dec;51(6):819-833. doi: 10.3138/jvme-2023-0017. Epub 2024 Dec 4.
"Neurophobia" is a phenomenon in human medical education where students develop negative attitudes towards neurology, impeding student learning and future clinical practice. While suspected to exist in veterinary medical education, it remains unstudied. The main objectives of this study were to examine North American veterinary student attitudes towards neurology and neurology education and explore elements that might contribute to neurophobia. Additional objectives were to evaluate veterinary educators' perceptions of student neurophobia and to develop and validate a scoring tool (VetNeuroQ) to quantify veterinary neurophobia. Veterinary students and faculty at North American veterinary schools were surveyed. A scoring tool was developed from a subset of questions and validated using confirmatory factor analysis. Six hundred six anonymous responses were collected from students at all stages of veterinary education. Neurology training was reported as insufficient by 35.9% and most respondents perceived neurology to not be easy to learn. Neuroanatomy/physiology and neurolocalization were considered difficult concepts. Students rated low confidence in neurology (vs. other topics), and low interest in the Neurology/Neurosurgery specialty. 61.7% of educators reported neurophobia amongst their students. The proposed VetNeuroQ scale showed high reliability (Cronbach's alpha >0.7) and validity ( < .05; CFI >0.9, RMSEA <0.08). VetNeuroQ scores were low but improved over the course of veterinary education. These findings demonstrate low self-efficacy, interest, and confidence, along with perceptions of difficulty, amongst veterinary students, consistent with neurophobia. Contributing elements are discussed. The VetNeuroQ scale allows quantification of veterinary student neurophobia and may be useful for screening students and assessing the impact of educational interventions.
“神经恐惧症”是人类医学教育中的一种现象,即学生对神经学产生消极态度,这会阻碍学生学习及未来的临床实践。虽然怀疑其在兽医医学教育中也存在,但尚未有相关研究。本研究的主要目的是调查北美兽医专业学生对神经学及神经学教育的态度,并探索可能导致神经恐惧症的因素。其他目的包括评估兽医教育工作者对学生神经恐惧症的认知,以及开发并验证一种评分工具(VetNeuroQ)来量化兽医领域的神经恐惧症。对北美兽医学院的兽医专业学生和教师进行了调查。从部分问题中开发了一种评分工具,并通过验证性因素分析进行了验证。收集了来自兽医教育各阶段学生的606份匿名回复。35.9%的学生报告称神经学培训不足,大多数受访者认为神经学不易学习。神经解剖学/生理学和神经定位被认为是较难的概念。学生对神经学(与其他主题相比)的信心较低,对神经学/神经外科学专业的兴趣也较低。61.7%的教育工作者报告称他们的学生存在神经恐惧症。所提出的VetNeuroQ量表显示出高信度(Cronbach's alpha>0.7)和效度(<.05;CFI>0.9,RMSEA<0.08)。VetNeuroQ分数较低,但在兽医教育过程中有所提高。这些发现表明,兽医专业学生存在自我效能感低、兴趣低和信心低以及感觉困难的情况,这与神经恐惧症相符。文中讨论了相关影响因素。VetNeuroQ量表能够量化兽医专业学生的神经恐惧症,可能有助于筛选学生以及评估教育干预措施的效果。