Guckian Jonathan, Edwards Sarah, Rees Eliot L, Burford Bryan
Advanced Medical Education Fellow and Dermatology Registrar, Leeds Institute for Medical Education, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Emergency Department, Queen's Medical Centre, University of Nottingham NHS Trust, NG7 2UH, Nottingham, UK.
Clin Teach. 2025 Feb;22(1):e13825. doi: 10.1111/tct.13825. Epub 2024 Nov 6.
Social Media (SoMe) as a learning tool, though ubiquitous in society and popular within medical education, is often criticised as superficial. Its limitless output has been blamed for encouraging shorter attention spans and shirking in-depth reflection. The evidence base is itself superficial and lacking rigour or meaning. We aimed to consider a theoretical basis for how 'quality' learning may happen on such platforms. Our findings then informed the construction of a taxonomy for SoMe learning.
We conducted a qualitative interview study of United Kingdom (UK) medical students using a theory-informed inductive study design. The research question was: 'How do medical students conceptualise quality of learning on social media?'. We purposively sampled participants from responses to a short survey collecting demographic and SoMe usage data. Interview data were analysed using framework analysis and informed by Blooms taxonomy, connectivism and communities of practice (CoP) theories.
We received survey responses from 118 medical students across 25 UK medical schools. From these, 13 participants were recruited to individual semi-structured interviews. We constructed three themes through framework analysis of interview data: cognitive hacking, professional identity reflection and safety, control and capital.
Quality SoMe learning may be conceptualised as a socially connected process, built upon constantly evolving networks but inexorably influenced by fluctuating hierarchy within learner-centric CoP. Educators and institutions may support high-quality learning for students through engagement which promotes community development, and safe, listening environments which foster professional identity formation.
社交媒体(SoMe)作为一种学习工具,虽然在社会中无处不在且在医学教育中颇受欢迎,但常被批评为流于表面。其海量的信息输出被指责导致注意力持续时间缩短,并逃避深入思考。其证据基础本身也很肤浅,缺乏严谨性和意义。我们旨在思考在这样的平台上如何实现“高质量”学习的理论基础。我们的研究结果随后为构建社交媒体学习的分类法提供了依据。
我们采用基于理论的归纳研究设计,对英国医学生进行了定性访谈研究。研究问题是:“医学生如何理解社交媒体上的学习质量?”我们从一份收集人口统计学和社交媒体使用数据的简短调查问卷的回复中,有目的地抽取参与者。访谈数据采用框架分析法进行分析,并以布鲁姆分类法、连接主义和实践社区(CoP)理论为依据。
我们收到了来自英国25所医学院校的118名医学生的调查问卷回复。从中招募了13名参与者进行个人半结构化访谈。通过对访谈数据的框架分析,我们构建了三个主题:认知黑客、职业身份反思以及安全、控制与资本。
高质量的社交媒体学习可被概念化为一个社会连接过程,建立在不断演变的网络之上,但不可避免地受到以学习者为中心的实践社区内波动层级的影响。教育工作者和机构可以通过促进社区发展的参与,以及培养职业身份形成的安全倾听环境,来支持学生进行高质量学习。