Kline D G, Mahaley M S
J Neurosurg. 1986 Apr;64(4):531-6. doi: 10.3171/jns.1986.64.4.0531.
In recent years, one-half of the 23 recognized specialty boards in medicine have begun formally to recognize subspecialization with some type of certification process. One such board, the American Board of Internal Medicine, examines and certifies in 11 subspecialty areas while the American Board of Pathology does so in nine, the American Board of Pediatrics in eight, the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology in four, and the American Board of General Surgery in three. Arguments for and against similar recognition of subspecialization within neurosurgery are reviewed. The present position of other specialties and their boards regarding this sensitive issue is summarized, as well as their certification structure. The various pathways available to certifying boards for recognition of subspecialization are also presented. The American Board of Neurological Surgery (ABNS) has approved a subspecialty certificate called a "certificate of Special Qualification in Critical Care Medicine." This is a subspecialty that is longitudinally oriented, touching on a number of other specialties in addition to neurosurgery, and thus differs from a vertical subspecialty such as Pediatric Neurosurgery or Cerebrovascular Neurosurgery. The background for development of such a certificate and the current requirements for obtaining it are reviewed. At the present time, the ABNS opposes the possible fragmentation of neurosurgery by offering certification in multiple subspecialty areas. Nonetheless, the current trend in medicine as a whole is in the direction of such subspecialization and its formal recognition. Increasing numbers of neurosurgeons tend to concentrate all or a good deal of their professional efforts in a specific area. Thus, organized neurosurgery must continue to consider methods for subspecialty recognition.
近年来,医学领域23个公认的专业委员会中有半数已开始通过某种认证程序正式认可亚专业。其中一个委员会,即美国内科医学委员会,在11个亚专业领域开展考核与认证工作;美国病理学委员会有9个亚专业;美国儿科学委员会有8个亚专业;美国妇产科学委员会有4个亚专业;美国普通外科学委员会有3个亚专业。本文回顾了支持和反对在神经外科领域类似认可亚专业的观点。总结了其他专业及其委员会在这个敏感问题上的当前立场,以及它们的认证结构。还介绍了认证委员会认可亚专业的各种途径。美国神经外科委员会(ABNS)已批准了一项名为“重症医学特殊资格证书”的亚专业证书。这是一个纵向发展的亚专业,除神经外科外还涉及许多其他专业,因此不同于如小儿神经外科或脑血管神经外科等垂直亚专业。本文回顾了设立此类证书的背景以及目前获得该证书的要求。目前,美国神经外科委员会反对通过在多个亚专业领域提供认证而可能导致的神经外科碎片化。尽管如此,医学整体的当前趋势是朝着这种亚专业划分及其正式认可的方向发展。越来越多的神经外科医生倾向于将全部或大量专业精力集中在特定领域。因此,有组织的神经外科必须继续考虑亚专业认可的方法。