1Department of Neurosurgery, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
2Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, Program for Global Surgery and Social Change, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
J Neurosurg. 2024 Jan 16;141(1):1-9. doi: 10.3171/2023.9.JNS231615. Print 2024 Jul 1.
It is unknown whether efforts to expand access to neurosurgery worldwide have translated to an increase in the global neurosurgery workforce, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. The main objective of this study was to quantify the number and distribution of consultant neurosurgeons worldwide, while also identifying temporal and geographic trends in the neurosurgery workforce in different income levels and WHO regions, and analyzing what factors might contribute to the growth of a national workforce.
This study was a subanalysis of an electronic cross-sectional survey administered to participants identified through neurosurgery societies, personal contacts, and online searches of all 193 countries and 26 territories, independent states, and disputed regions as defined by the World Bank (WB) and United Nations between October 2022 and March 2023. Population-weighted statistics for the consultant neurosurgery workforce and resource availability were estimated, and linear regression analysis was conducted to identify correlations with growth in the workforce.
Data were obtained for 192 countries (99.5%) and 25 additional territories, states, and disputed regions (96.2%). One hundred seventy-seven respondents participated in the survey. There were an estimated 72,967 neurosurgeons worldwide, representing a global pooled density of 0.93 neurosurgeons per 100,000 people and a median country density of 0.44 neurosurgeons per 100,000 people. The authors found an increasing density of consultant neurosurgeons, from low-income countries (0.12 per 100,000 people), to lower-middle-income countries (LoMICs; 0.37), to upper-middle-income countries (UpMICs; 1.13), and to high-income countries (2.44). The WHO African and Southeast Asia regions had the lowest pooled neurosurgeon density, while the Western Pacific region (WPR) had the highest density. There were 29 countries, 14 territories, and 1 independent state with no neurosurgeons. Neurosurgeons in countries with higher income-level designations had more frequent access to resources and equipment. The annual growth rates in workforce density were highest in LoMICs (26.0%) and UpMICs (21.3%), and the most rapid annual growth was in the Southeast Asia region (33.0%). Regression analysis revealed that an increasing population quartile, the Eastern Mediterranean region (relative to the WPR), the presence of a national neurosurgery society, increasing global development aid, and national gross domestic product were associated with relative growth in national neurosurgeon density.
The authors estimate a global consultant neurosurgeon workforce of nearly 73,000 neurosurgeons, with stark disparities in the density and growth of the workforce in different WB income-level groups and WHO regions. The presence of a neurosurgery society was correlated with the growth of the workforce, and this study identified several regional targets for further intervention to expand access to neurosurgery.
目前尚不清楚全球扩大神经外科服务可及性的努力是否导致全球神经外科劳动力增加,特别是在低收入和中等收入国家。本研究的主要目的是量化全球神经外科顾问的数量和分布,同时确定不同收入水平和世界卫生组织(WHO)区域神经外科劳动力的时间和地理趋势,并分析哪些因素可能有助于国家劳动力的增长。
本研究是对 2022 年 10 月至 2023 年 3 月期间通过神经外科学会、个人联系以及对世界银行(WB)和联合国定义的所有 193 个国家和 26 个领土、独立国家和有争议地区的在线搜索向参与者发送的电子横断面调查的子分析。估计了顾问神经外科劳动力和资源可用性的人口加权统计数据,并进行了线性回归分析以确定与劳动力增长的相关性。
共获得 192 个国家(99.5%)和 25 个额外的领土、州和有争议地区(96.2%)的数据。177 名受访者参加了调查。全球有 72967 名神经外科医生,全球总体密度为每 10 万人中有 0.93 名神经外科医生,中位数为每 10 万人中有 0.44 名神经外科医生。作者发现顾问神经外科医生的密度在增加,从低收入国家(每 10 万人中有 0.12 名)到中低收入国家(LoMICs;每 10 万人中有 0.37 名),到中高收入国家(UpMICs;每 10 万人中有 1.13 名),再到高收入国家(每 10 万人中有 2.44 名)。世界卫生组织非洲和东南亚地区的神经外科医生总体密度最低,而西太平洋地区(WPR)的密度最高。有 29 个国家、14 个领土和 1 个独立国家没有神经外科医生。收入水平较高的国家的神经外科医生获得资源和设备的机会更多。LoMICs(26.0%)和 UpMICs(21.3%)的劳动力密度年增长率最高,东南亚地区(33.0%)的年增长率最快。回归分析显示,人口四分位区间增加、东地中海地区(相对于 WPR)、国家神经外科学会的存在、全球发展援助增加以及国民生产总值与国家神经外科医生密度的相对增长有关。
作者估计全球有近 73000 名顾问神经外科医生,但在不同世界银行收入水平组和世界卫生组织区域的劳动力密度和增长方面存在明显差异。神经外科学会的存在与劳动力的增长有关,本研究确定了几个区域目标,以进一步干预扩大神经外科服务的可及性。