Comprehensive evaluation of the impact of whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS) on the fragmentomic characteristics of plasma cell-free DNA.

BACKGROUND

Cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is non-randomly fragmented in human body fluids. Analyzing such fragmentation patterns of cfDNA holds great promise for liquid biopsy. Whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS) is widely used for cfDNA methylation profiling. However, its applicability for studying fragmentomic characteristics remains largely unexplored.

METHODS

We performed paired WGBS and whole-genome sequencing (WGS) on 66 peripheral plasma samples from 58 pregnant women. Then, we systematically compared the fragmentation patterns of cell-free nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequenced from these two approaches. Additionally, we evaluated the extent of the size shortening in fetal-derived cfDNA and estimated the fetal DNA fraction in maternal plasma using both sequencing methods.

RESULTS

Compared to WGS samples, WGBS samples demonstrated a significantly lower genome coverage and higher GC content in cfDNA. They also showed a significant decrease in the size of cell-free nuclear DNA, along with alterations in the end motif pattern that were specifically associated with CpG and "CC" sites. While there was a slight shift in the inferred nucleosome footprint from cfDNA coverages in WGBS samples, the cfDNA coverage patterns in CTCF and TSS regions remained highly consistent between these two sequencing methods. Both methods accurately reflected gene expression levels through their TSS coverages. Additionally, WGBS samples exhibited an increased abundance and longer length of mtDNA in plasma. Furthermore, we observed the size shortening of fetal cfDNA in plasma consistently, with a highly correlated fetal DNA fraction inferred by cfDNA coverage between WGBS and WGS samples (r = 0.996). However, the estimated fetal cfDNA fraction in WGBS samples was approximately 7 % lower than in WGS samples.

CONCLUSIONS

We confirmed that WGBS can introduce artificial breakages to cfDNA, leading to altered fragmentomic patterns in both nuclear and mitochondrial DNA. However, WGBS cfDNA remains suitable for analyzing certain cfDNA fragmentomic characteristics, such as coverage in genome regulation regions and the essential characteristics of fetal DNA in maternal plasma.