Forsythe Desiree, Dewsbury Bryan, Hsu Jeremy L
Department of Biological Sciences, Santa Clara University, Santa Clara, CA 95053.
Department of Biological Sciences, Florida International University, Miami, FL 33131.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2024 Dec;23(4):ar60. doi: 10.1187/cbe.24-02-0063.
In higher education and science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), interlocking oppressions can lead to inequitable environments for those who hold marginalized identities. Instructors can play key roles in either exacerbating or mitigating these inequities through their pedagogical approaches and choice of curricular material. However, it remains unclear how instructors who self-identify as committed to justice achieve higher levels of consciousness around areas of injustice and develop the self-efficacy to dismantle barriers for students over time. Here, we draw upon critical race theory and critical white studies to investigate what events or life experiences influence STEM instructors to understand the importance of social justice and examine how STEM instructors use this understanding to drive pedagogical shifts. We find variations in the ways that instructors' experiences and identities shape their understanding of justice. In addition, we uncover factors that influence the switch moment; curriculum and pedagogical shifts; their relationship to justice work broadly; and barriers and supports for justice work. These stories hold powerful lessons for STEM education, but also for education more broadly, both in terms of pedagogical practice and the questions that shape research agendas on equity in education.
在高等教育和科学、技术、工程和数学(STEM)领域,连锁压迫可能导致那些具有边缘化身份的人处于不平等的环境中。教师可以通过他们的教学方法和课程材料的选择,在加剧或减轻这些不平等方面发挥关键作用。然而,目前尚不清楚那些自认为致力于正义的教师如何在不公正领域提高意识水平,并随着时间的推移培养为学生消除障碍的自我效能感。在这里,我们借鉴批判种族理论和批判白人研究,探讨是什么事件或生活经历促使 STEM 教师认识到社会正义的重要性,并研究 STEM 教师如何利用这种理解来推动教学转变。我们发现,教师的经验和身份对他们对正义的理解的影响方式存在差异。此外,我们还揭示了影响转变时刻、课程和教学转变的因素,以及它们与正义工作的广泛关系,以及正义工作的障碍和支持。这些故事为 STEM 教育提供了有力的教训,也为更广泛的教育提供了教训,无论是在教学实践方面,还是在影响教育公平研究议程的问题方面。