Paterson Lindsay, Wen Fangqi, Breen Richard, Iannelli Cristina, In Jung
School of Social and Political Science, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
Department of Sociology, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA.
Br J Sociol. 2025 Mar;76(2):241-259. doi: 10.1111/1468-4446.13162. Epub 2024 Nov 17.
Changes in the social mobility of men in Scotland between the late-19th and the late-twentieth century are examined using new individual-level data from nineteenth-century censuses, linking records of men aged 0-19 in 1871 to their records in 1901, and then comparing their patterns with the social mobility of men aged 30-49 in 1974 and in 2001 as recorded in social surveys at these dates. The extent of social mobility in the nineteenth century was large. In particular, the social origins of people in the highest classes-the salariat-were very varied, indicating a society that was more open than is sometimes supposed. There was a slow growth in social mobility between then and 2001. In both periods, class inheritance-sons in the same social class as their father-was strongest in the economically declining sectors, which were agriculture and fisheries in 1901 and industry in 1974 and 2001. In the 1901 data, however, the transition to a non-agricultural economy induced strong outward mobility from agriculture.
利用19世纪人口普查的新个体层面数据,研究了19世纪末至20世纪末苏格兰男性社会流动性的变化。将1871年0至19岁男性的记录与他们1901年的记录相联系,然后将他们的模式与1974年和2001年30至49岁男性的社会流动性模式进行比较,这些数据来自当时的社会调查记录。19世纪的社会流动性程度很大。特别是,最高阶层(即工薪阶层)人群的社会出身非常多样,这表明当时的社会比人们有时认为的更加开放。从那时到2001年,社会流动性增长缓慢。在这两个时期,阶级继承(儿子与父亲处于同一社会阶层)在经济衰退部门最为明显,1901年是农业和渔业,1974年及2001年是工业。然而,在1901年的数据中,向非农业经济的转变导致了农业人口的强劲外流。