Madkikar N N, Pandey Shailesh, Ghaisas Virendra, Agashe Ajit, Chitre Himanshu
Inamdar Multispecialty Hosp Pune, Ghaisas Ent Hospital, Pune, India.
Prime ENT Clinic Andheri Mumbai, Mumbai, India.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2024 Dec;76(6):5672-5681. doi: 10.1007/s12070-024-05059-y. Epub 2024 Oct 8.
Obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome (OSA) is a multi-factorial disorder, with quite complex endotypes, consisting of anatomical and non-anatomical pathophysiological factors. Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) is recognized as the first-line standard treatment for OSA, whereas upper airway (UA) surgery is often recommended for treating mild OSA patients who have refused or cannot tolerate CPAP, mild and primary snorers. The main results achievable by the surgery are UA expansion, and/or stabilization, and/or removal of the obstructive tissue to different UA levels. The site and pattern of UA collapse identification is of upmost importance in selecting the customized surgical procedure to perform, as well as the identification of the relation between anatomical and non-anatomical factors in each patient. It has become increasingly clear in the past decade that surgical management of OSA is most successfully managed with multilevel surgery (Cahali in Laryngoscope, 113(11):1961-1968, 2003; Friedman et al. in Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 131(1):89-100, 2004; Laryngoscope 114(3):441-449, 2004; Pang Woodson in Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 137(1):110-114, 2007; Li Lee in Laryngoscope 119(12):2472-2477, 2009; Vicini et al. in Head Neck 36(1):77-78, 2014; Mantovani et al. in Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital 32:48-53, 2012; Morgenthaler in Sleep 30(4):519-529, 2007). Drug-induced sleep endoscopy (DISE) has shown that the nose amounting more than 50% of flow limitation and soft palatal collapse are important anatomic components of obstruction in OSAHS and therefore should be treated as far as possible as a single stage procedure. The nasal patency being pivotal in the outcome of the sleep apnoea surgery. Choosing the right patient and the right surgical approach for such patients is extremely important to decrease the overall burden of the disease. We have chosen functional rhinoplasty or an open approach septoplasty for management of various nasal deformities that lead to significant obstruction in patients suffering from snoring and mild OSA. While the palatal component of obstruction being treated with BRP (BARB Relocation Palatoplasty) for anterior- posterior, lateral and concentric collapses at retro palatal level. (1) To be able to offer an effective and reliable surgical management to simple snorers, Mild OSA, upper airway resistance patients, PAP non-compliant or non-adherent patients. (2) To ascertain the effectiveness and ease of carrying out multilevel single stage procedure in above mentioned patients of snorers to mild obstructive sleep apnoea, and to use Functional Rhinoplasty & BARB sutures for relocation and suspension Palatoplasty to address retro palatal collapse without excising soft palatal tissue. (3) To make minor modification in the surgical steps namely - bundling of the posterior pillar after release to avoid cut through or spillage of the barb suture from point of relocation. (4) Identifying surgical candidacy for better outcomes in terms of reduction of disease burden and better quality of life. We have carried out a prospective observational multicentre study of 120 OSA (mild) patients over a period of 8 years who underwent open approach septoplasty / functional rhinoplasty along with Barb relocation and suspension Palatoplasty for mild obstructive sleep apnoea with a mean follow up of 3 years. Patients with nasal and retro palatal collapse diagnosed on 4-phase rhinomanometry and DISE respectively having mild sleep apnoea (AASM Definition-AHI < 15, Hypopnea - 3% desaturation and 30% reduction in flow for more than 10 s). Patients having retroglossal or hypo pharyngeal collapse or primary epiglottis collapse were excluded from the study. Patients having moderate to severe OSA and severe OSA (AHI > 15) on HST were also excluded from the study. Simple snorers and patients complaining of daytime sleepiness or cognitive impairment, with no comorbidities and ones refusing to use or non-adherent to PAP therapy were chosen. All patients underwent a level 2 sleep study, rhinomanometry and a DISE with consent. The nasal obstructive component of obstruction was treated via a functional rhinoplasty/ extracorporeal septoplasty approach. Retro palatal component addressed by barbed relocation Palatoplasty (BRP). All 120 patients underwent an open approach septoplasty with Barb Relocation Palatoplasty under GA. We observed that open approach septoplasty can help us address the nasal obstructive component in a much more efficient way to correct not only internal but also external nasal valve deformities along with gross septal deformities to relieve obstructions adequately and efficiently. An adequately done nasal surgery along with BRP can provide as an effective and safe option with very promising results in this era of multi-level single stage procedures. Adding BRP in the same stage with nasal surgery has been proved to be a simplebut effective procedure for simple snorers and patients with mild obstructive sleep apnoea.
阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停综合征(OSA)是一种多因素疾病,具有相当复杂的内型,由解剖学和非解剖学病理生理因素组成。持续气道正压通气(CPAP)被认为是OSA的一线标准治疗方法,而上气道(UA)手术通常推荐用于治疗拒绝或无法耐受CPAP的轻度OSA患者、轻度和原发性打鼾者。手术可实现的主要结果是UA扩张、和/或稳定、和/或去除不同UA水平的阻塞组织。UA塌陷识别的部位和模式在选择定制的手术程序以及识别每个患者的解剖学和非解剖学因素之间的关系方面至关重要。在过去十年中越来越清楚的是,OSA的手术管理通过多级手术最成功(Cahali于《喉镜》,113(11):1961 - 1968,2003年;Friedman等人于《耳鼻喉头颈外科》131(1):89 - 100,2004年;《喉镜》114(3):441 - 449,2004年;Pang Woodson于《耳鼻喉头颈外科》137(1):110 - 114,2007年;Li Lee于《喉镜》119(12):2472 - 2477,2009年;Vicini等人于《头颈》36(1):77 - 78,2014年;Mantovani等人于《意大利耳鼻喉科学学报》32:48 - 53,2012年;Morgenthaler于《睡眠》30(4):519 - 529,2007年)。药物诱导睡眠内镜检查(DISE)表明,超过50%的气流受限和软腭塌陷的鼻子是OSAHS阻塞的重要解剖组成部分,因此应尽可能作为单阶段手术进行治疗。鼻腔通畅在睡眠呼吸暂停手术的结果中至关重要。为这类患者选择合适的患者和正确的手术方法对于减轻疾病的总体负担极为重要。我们选择功能性鼻整形术或开放式鼻中隔成形术来处理导致打鼾和轻度OSA患者严重阻塞的各种鼻畸形。而阻塞的腭部成分则采用BRP(BARB重新定位腭成形术)治疗腭后水平的前后、外侧和同心塌陷。(1)能够为单纯打鼾者、轻度OSA、上气道阻力患者、PAP不依从或不坚持使用的患者提供有效且可靠的手术管理。(2)确定在上述打鼾至轻度阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停患者中进行多级单阶段手术的有效性和简便性,并使用功能性鼻整形术和BARB缝线进行重新定位和悬吊腭成形术以解决腭后塌陷而不切除软腭组织。(3)对手术步骤进行微小修改,即 - 在释放后捆绑后柱以避免倒刺缝线从重新定位点切断或溢出。(4)确定手术候选资格以在减轻疾病负担和提高生活质量方面获得更好的结果。我们对120例轻度OSA患者进行了为期8年的前瞻性观察多中心研究,这些患者接受了开放式鼻中隔成形术/功能性鼻整形术以及用于轻度阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停的倒刺重新定位和悬吊腭成形术,平均随访3年。分别通过四阶段鼻阻力测量和DISE诊断为鼻腔和腭后塌陷且患有轻度睡眠呼吸暂停(AASM定义 - AHI < 15,呼吸暂停 - 3%血氧饱和度下降和气流减少30%超过10秒)的患者。患有舌后或下咽塌陷或原发性会厌塌陷的患者被排除在研究之外。HST显示患有中度至重度OSA和重度OSA(AHI > 15)的患者也被排除在研究之外。选择单纯打鼾者以及抱怨白天嗜睡或认知障碍、无合并症且拒绝使用或不坚持使用PAP治疗的患者。所有患者均在获得同意后接受二级睡眠研究、鼻阻力测量和DISE。阻塞的鼻腔阻塞成分通过功能性鼻整形术/体外鼻中隔成形术方法治疗。腭后成分通过带倒刺重新定位腭成形术(BRP)处理。所有120例患者在全身麻醉下接受开放式鼻中隔成形术加倒刺重新定位腭成形术。我们观察到开放式鼻中隔成形术可以帮助我们更有效地解决鼻腔阻塞成分,不仅可以纠正内部而且可以纠正外部鼻瓣畸形以及严重的鼻中隔畸形,以充分且有效地缓解阻塞。在这个多级单阶段手术的时代,充分进行的鼻腔手术以及BRP可以提供一种有效且安全的选择,结果非常有前景。在鼻腔手术的同一阶段添加BRP已被证明是一种简单但有效的方法,适用于单纯打鼾者和轻度阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停患者。