Heart failure (HF) is a complex syndrome and a leading cause of mortality worldwide. While current medical treatment is based on known pathophysiology and is effective for many patients, the underlying cellular mechanisms are poorly understood. Energy deficiency is a characteristic of HF, marked by complex alterations in metabolism. Within the tricarboxylic acid cycle, anaplerosis emerges as an essential metabolic process responsible for replenishing lost intermediates, thereby playing a crucial role in sustaining energy metabolism and consequently cardiac function. Alterations in cardiac anaplerosis are commonly observed in HF, demonstrating potential for therapeutic intervention. This review discusses recent advances in understanding the anaplerotic adaptations that occur in HF. We also explore therapeutics that can directly modulate anaplerosis or are likely to confer cardioprotective effects through anaplerosis, which could potentially be implemented to rescue the failing heart.