Pham Linh, Guma Elisa, Ellegood Jacob, Lerch Jason P, Raznahan Armin
Section on Developmental Neurogenomics, Human Genetics Branch, National Institute of Mental Health, Bethesda, 20892, Maryland.
Mouse Imaging Centre, Toronto, Ontario M5T 3H7, Canada.
bioRxiv. 2024 Nov 5:2024.11.05.622111. doi: 10.1101/2024.11.05.622111.
Structural covariance in brain anatomy is thought to reflect inter-regional sharing of developmental influences - although this hypothesis has proved hard to causally test. Here, we use neuroimaging in humans and mice to study sex-differences in anatomical covariance - asking if regions that have developed shared sex differences in volume across species also show shared sex difference in volume covariance. This study design illuminates both the biology of sex-differences and theoretical models for anatomical covariance - benefitting from tests of inter-species convergence. We find that volumetric structural covariance is stronger in adult females compared to adult males for both wild-type mice and healthy human subjects: 98% of all comparisons with statistically significant covariance sex differences in mice are female-biased, while 76% of all such comparisons are female-biased in humans (q < 0.05). In both species, a region's covariance and volumetric sex-biases have weak inverse relationships to each other: volumetrically male-biased regions contain more female-biased covariations, while volumetrically female-biased regions have more male-biased covariations (mice: r = -0.185, p = 0.002; humans: r = -0.189, p = 0.001). Our results identify a conserved tendency for females to show stronger neuroanatomical covariance than males, evident across species, which suggests that stronger structural covariance in females could be an evolutionarily conserved feature that is partially related to volumetric alterations through sex.
脑解剖结构的协方差被认为反映了发育影响的区域间共享——尽管这一假设已被证明难以进行因果检验。在这里,我们使用人类和小鼠的神经影像学来研究解剖协方差中的性别差异——探究在跨物种体积上出现了共同性别差异的区域在体积协方差上是否也表现出共同的性别差异。这种研究设计阐明了性别差异的生物学机制以及解剖协方差的理论模型——受益于种间趋同的检验。我们发现,对于野生型小鼠和健康人类受试者,成年雌性的体积结构协方差比成年雄性更强:在小鼠中,所有具有统计学显著协方差性别差异的比较中有98%偏向雌性,而在人类中,所有此类比较中有76%偏向雌性(q < 0.05)。在这两个物种中,一个区域的协方差和体积性别偏向之间的关系较弱且呈负相关:体积上偏向雄性的区域包含更多偏向雌性的协变,而体积上偏向雌性的区域有更多偏向雄性的协变(小鼠:r = -0.185,p = 0.002;人类:r = -0.189,p = 0.001)。我们的研究结果确定了一种保守的趋势,即雌性比雄性表现出更强的神经解剖协方差,这在跨物种中都很明显,这表明雌性更强的结构协方差可能是一种进化上保守的特征,部分与通过性别导致的体积变化有关。