Grewal Harmanpreet Singh, Qi Zhiming, Shedekar Vinayak, King Kevin
Department of Bioresource Engineering, McGill University, Sainte-Anne-De-Bellevue, Québec, Canada.
Department of Food, Agricultural and Biological Engineering, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA.
J Environ Qual. 2025 Jan-Feb;54(1):217-232. doi: 10.1002/jeq2.20656. Epub 2024 Nov 25.
Phosphorus (P) loading from tile-drained agricultural lands is linked to water quality and aquatic ecosystem degradation. The RZWQM2-P model was developed to simulate the fate and transport of P in soil-water-plant systems, especially in tile-drained croplands. Comprehensive evaluation and application of RZWQM2-P, however, remains limited. This study evaluates RZWQM2-P in simulating P dynamics using extensive data and assesses the potential of management practices for mitigating P losses. Subsurface drainage and surface runoff flows were monitored at a tile-drained site from 2017 to 2020 in Ohio, and the water flow and P loss data were summarized on a daily basis. RZWQM2-P was calibrated and validated using those observed data and was subsequently used to assess the effectiveness of controlled drainage (CD) and winter cover crops (CC) in reducing P losses. The model satisfactorily simulated dissolved reactive P (DRP) loss from tile drainage on daily and monthly bases (Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency [NSE] = 0.50, R= 0.52, index of agreement [IoA] = 0.84 for daily; NSE = 0.73, R= 0.78, IoA = 0.94 for monthly) and total P (TP) loss on a monthly basis (NSE = 0.64, R= 0.65, IoA = 0.88), but the daily TP simulation was less accurate (NSE = 0.30, R= 0.30, IoA = 0.59). Simulations showed that winter rye CC reduced DRP by 16% and TP by 4% compared to the base scenario, whereas CD increased DRP (60%-129%) and TP (5%-17%) losses at three tested outlet elevations compared to free drainage. RZWQM2-P can capture P dynamics in tile-drained cropland and is a promising tool for effective P management.
来自瓦管排水农田的磷(P)负荷与水质和水生生态系统退化有关。RZWQM2-P模型旨在模拟土壤-水-植物系统中磷的归宿和迁移,特别是在瓦管排水的农田中。然而,RZWQM2-P的综合评估和应用仍然有限。本研究使用大量数据评估RZWQM2-P在模拟磷动态方面的表现,并评估管理措施减轻磷流失的潜力。2017年至2020年期间,在俄亥俄州一个瓦管排水场地监测了地下排水和地表径流,每天汇总水流和磷流失数据。利用这些观测数据对RZWQM2-P进行了校准和验证,随后用于评估控制排水(CD)和冬季覆盖作物(CC)减少磷流失的有效性。该模型在每日和每月尺度上令人满意地模拟了瓦管排水中溶解态活性磷(DRP)的流失(每日:Nash-Sutcliffe效率 [NSE]=0.50,R=0.52,一致性指数 [IoA]=0.84;每月:NSE=0.73,R=0.78,IoA=0.94)以及每月总磷(TP)的流失(NSE=0.64,R=0.65,IoA=0.88),但每日TP模拟的准确性较低(NSE=0.30,R=0.30,IoA=0.59)。模拟结果表明,与基础情景相比,冬黑麦覆盖作物使DRP减少了16%,TP减少了4%,而与自由排水相比,在三个测试出口高程下,控制排水增加了DRP(60%-129%)和TP(5%-17%)的流失。RZWQM2-P能够捕捉瓦管排水农田中的磷动态,是有效管理磷的一个有前景的工具。