Moore Stephanie Pike, Ennis Alysha C, Kirihara Sho, Gomez Elvia C, Reyes-Klein Maya, Sharp Hannah, Macisco Joseph M, Trapl Erika S, Quisenberry Amanda J, Klein Elizabeth G
Department of Population and Quantitative Health Sciences, School of Medicine, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, United States of America.
College of Public Health, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, United States of America.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024 Nov 27;4(11):e0003840. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0003840. eCollection 2024.
Flavoring in cigarillos contributes to greater product initiation and abuse liability particularly among young adults. Few studies have examined how packaging elements, including flavor, may draw visual attention from potential consumers as well as impact product recall. This study aimed to test the difference in visual attention to flavor names and other packaging elements on cigarillo products as well as recall of these packaging elements.
Young adults aged 16-28 years were recruited to participate in a randomized control trial (Clinictrials.org ID: NCT04358705) in June through December 2022 (N = 89). Participants were randomized to two conditions viewing 12 flavored or unflavored cigarillo package images. Eye tracking software captured participants viewing (dwell) time on package features: flavor, brand, health warning, price, and other package imagery. Participants were asked about their recall of the images viewed. The proportion of dwell time on each package elements were used to examine differences between experimental conditions.
Across conditions, participants spent the greatest proportion of dwell time looking at the health warning. Participants in the flavored condition spent a significantly greater proportion of dwell time looking at flavor name (mean: 10.66%; SD: 3.56) compared to those in the unflavored condition (mean:7.03%; SD 2.81). Following the experiment, 45.8% of those in the flavored condition recalled having seen flavors or flavor names, which was greater than recall of all other elements and was significantly greater than flavor recall in the unflavored condition (12.2%).
Flavored cigarillos attract greater visual attention and were the most memorable element of cigarillo packaging among young adults sampled. Changes to cigarillo packaging, including limiting flavor descriptors, imagery, and/or color on packaging and advertisements may be an effective way to reduce young adults' attention to the products and thus their appeal.
小雪茄中的调味剂会促使更多人开始吸食该产品,并增加其成瘾风险,在年轻人中尤为如此。很少有研究探讨包括口味在内的包装元素如何吸引潜在消费者的视觉注意力以及影响产品记忆度。本研究旨在测试对小雪茄产品口味名称和其他包装元素的视觉注意力差异以及对这些包装元素的记忆度。
招募了16至28岁的年轻人参与一项随机对照试验(Clinicaltrials.org标识符:NCT04358705),时间为2022年6月至12月(N = 89)。参与者被随机分为两组,观看12张有口味或无口味的小雪茄包装图片。眼动追踪软件记录参与者在包装特征上的观看(停留)时间,这些特征包括口味、品牌、健康警示、价格和其他包装图案。参与者被问及对所观看图片的记忆情况。每个包装元素的停留时间比例用于检验不同实验条件之间的差异。
在所有条件下,参与者观看健康警示的停留时间比例最高。与无口味条件组(平均:7.03%;标准差:2.81)相比,有口味条件组的参与者观看口味名称的停留时间比例显著更高(平均:10.66%;标准差:3.56)。实验结束后,有口味条件组中45.8%的人回忆起看到过口味或口味名称,这一比例高于对所有其他元素的回忆比例,且显著高于无口味条件组中的口味回忆比例(12.2%)。
有口味的小雪茄吸引了更多的视觉注意力,并且是抽样的年轻人中小雪茄包装中最令人难忘的元素。改变小雪茄包装,包括限制包装和广告上的口味描述、图案和/或颜色,可能是减少年轻人对该产品的关注从而降低其吸引力的有效方法。