Cronin Thomas, Gendy David, Johnston Jennifer L
The North Dublin GP Training Scheme, Irish College of General Practitioners, Ireland, UK.
Department of Radiology, Whiston Hospital, Prescot, UK.
Educ Prim Care. 2025 Jan-Mar;36(1-2):6-15. doi: 10.1080/14739879.2024.2426130. Epub 2024 Nov 28.
Widening participation in medicine refers to the recruitment policy of encouraging those who are traditionally under-represented in medical school. Whilst research in the UK has investigated the processes around improving participation through recruitment and selection to medical schools, there is less focus around the period after medical school and how students from widening participation backgrounds fare in the workforce.
This study employed scoping review methodology to collate, map and summarise research in the field. Basic numerical analysis and thematic analysis were performed on the included studies.
A total of 17 studies were included in this scoping review. The majority of included studies were perspective pieces and cohort studies. There was a paucity of studies reporting around the impact of widening participation of doctors with a disability on the workforce. Four themes emerged from the thematic analysis: (1) promoting diversity; (2) boosting recruitment and retention; (3) improving representation and balance; and (4) perpetuating inequalities.
This scoping review highlighted positive effects on the workforce of widening participation. Efforts should be undertaken to ensure widening participation students do not experience ongoing inequality in their subsequent careers on qualification from medical school. The research field would benefit from further study exploring the impact of disability on the medical workforce, and qualitative enquiry to better investigate the experiences of widening participation students in the workforce.
医学领域扩大参与度是指鼓励那些在医学院中传统上代表性不足的人群的招生政策。虽然英国的研究调查了通过医学院招生和选拔来提高参与度的相关过程,但较少关注医学院毕业后的阶段以及来自扩大参与背景的学生在劳动力市场中的表现。
本研究采用范围综述方法来整理、梳理和总结该领域的研究。对纳入的研究进行了基本的数值分析和主题分析。
本范围综述共纳入17项研究。纳入的研究大多是观点性文章和队列研究。关于残疾医生扩大参与度对劳动力市场的影响的研究较少。主题分析得出了四个主题:(1)促进多样性;(2)提高招聘和留用率;(3)改善代表性和平衡性;(4)延续不平等现象。
本范围综述强调了扩大参与度对劳动力市场的积极影响。应努力确保扩大参与度的学生在医学院毕业后的后续职业生涯中不会持续面临不平等。进一步研究残疾对医学劳动力的影响,以及进行定性调查以更好地探究扩大参与度的学生在劳动力市场中的经历,将使该研究领域受益。