Gangarosa Department of Environmental Health, Emory University, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
SNV (Stichting Nederlandse Vrijwilligers), The Hague, The Netherlands.
Environ Health Perspect. 2024 Nov;132(11):117006. doi: 10.1289/EHP14780. Epub 2024 Nov 28.
Accurate information on context and implementation of public health interventions is necessary to replicate, adapt, and scale effective interventions and to interpret evaluations. Reporting the context and implementation of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions has been inconsistent and incomplete.
To improve the reporting of WASH interventions, we developed the Template for Intervention Description and Replication for WASH (TIDieR-WASH) checklist and guide, by adapting and expanding the original TIDieR guide. We performed a scoping review of existing implementation reporting guidelines, and of current implementation reporting in WASH evaluations, to develop a list of candidate items to include in this checklist. We then used a 4-stages of review by international experts to reach consensus.
The resulting 14-item checklist comprises: ) name, ) theory of change, ) prior evidence, ) location and setting, ) context, ) suitability, ) implementers, ) recipients, ) targeting, ) activities, ) intervention dose, ) fidelity, ) costs, and ) materials. Definitions, explanations, examples, and instructions for use are reported in this article.
The checklist can be applied to all types of evaluations of WASH interventions, including direct service provision, behavior change, and systems strengthening interventions. We deliberately developed this guidance document to be accessible and relevant to practitioners and researchers. Adoption of this checklist will support transparent reporting of WASH implementation for research and practice. As with other sectors that have used TIDieR checklists, clear implementation reporting can assist with evidence synthesis, adaptation, and policy guidance. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP14780.
准确了解公共卫生干预措施的背景和实施情况对于复制、调整和扩大有效干预措施以及解释评估结果是必要的。目前,水、环境卫生和个人卫生(WASH)干预措施的背景和实施情况报告一直存在不一致和不完整的问题。
为了改进 WASH 干预措施的报告,我们通过改编和扩展原始 TIDieR 指南,为 WASH 制定了干预措施描述和复制模板(TIDieR-WASH)清单和指南。我们对现有的实施情况报告指南以及当前 WASH 评估中的实施情况报告进行了范围审查,以确定纳入本清单的候选项目列表。然后,我们使用国际专家的四阶段审查来达成共识。
由此产生的 14 项清单包括:(1)名称,(2)变革理论,(3)前期证据,(4)地点和背景,(5)背景,(6)适宜性,(7)执行者,(8)接受者,(9)针对性,(10)活动,(11)干预剂量,(12)保真度,(13)成本,和(14)材料。本文还报告了定义、解释、示例和使用说明。
该清单可应用于 WASH 干预措施的所有类型评估,包括直接服务提供、行为改变和系统强化干预措施。我们有意制定本指南文件,使其易于从业者和研究人员使用。采用本清单将支持 WASH 实施情况的透明报告,以用于研究和实践。与使用 TIDieR 清单的其他部门一样,明确的实施情况报告可以协助综合证据、调整和政策指导。