Burnett Eleanor, Umana Jazmina, Anwari Palwasha, Mujuru Hilda A, Groome Michele J, Van Trang Nguyen, Iniguez Volga, Gheorghita Stela, Sahakyan Gayane, Nazurdinov Anvar, Michael Fausta, Mandomando Inacio, Desormeaux Anne Marie, Eraliev Umid, Enweronu-Laryea Christabel, Nalunkuma Cissy, Bonkoungou Isidore, Muhsen Khitam, Luhata Lungayo Christophe, Omore Richard, Goldfarb David M, Robinson Annick Lalaina, McCracken John, Uwimana Jeannine, N'Zue Kofi, Rey-Benito Gloria, Weldegebriel Goitom, Mwenda Jason M, Parashar Umesh D, Tate Jacqueline E
Division of Viral Diseases, NCIRD, CDC, Atlanta, GA, USA.
Expanded Program on Immunization, Managua, Nicaragua.
J Infect Dis. 2024 Nov 28. doi: 10.1093/infdis/jiae597.
Rotavirus vaccines are moderately protective against illness in high mortality settings compared with low mortality settings. Vaccine effectiveness (VE) evaluations may clarify our understanding of these disparities, but estimates among key subpopulations and against rare outcomes are not available in many analyses due to sample size. We combined 25 datasets from test-negative design case-control evaluations in 24 countries that enrolled children with medically-attended diarrhea, laboratory-confirmed rotavirus stool testing, and documented vaccination status. We calculated rotavirus VE stratified by country-level characteristics.
Children 3-59 months old with birthdates and surveillance hospital arrival dates were included; other variables were standardized as available. Children were considered vaccinated if they received ≥1 dose of rotavirus vaccine >14 days before arrival. We summarized child- and country- level characteristics, including national <5-year-old child mortality rate (U5M). Following the manufacturer recommended dose schedule, complete- and partial-series adjusted VE were estimated using logistic regression models.
We included 6,626 rotavirus positive children (cases) and 19,459 rotavirus negative children (controls). Adjusted complete series VE was significantly higher among children from countries in the low and medium U5M strata (74% (95%CI: 64-81)) compared to all groups within the high U5M strata (range: 52% (95%CI: 42- 60) to 46% (95%CI: 31-57)). Partial series were lower than complete series estimates.
These findings are consistent with the published literature, though they suggest heterogeneity in vaccine performance within broad child mortality levels. Our findings also highlight the importance of complete-series vaccination.
与低死亡率环境相比,轮状病毒疫苗在高死亡率环境中对疾病的保护作用中等。疫苗效力(VE)评估可能会阐明我们对这些差异的理解,但由于样本量的原因,许多分析中无法获得关键亚人群的估计值以及针对罕见结局的估计值。我们合并了来自24个国家的25个检测阴性设计病例对照评估数据集,这些数据集纳入了有就医腹泻、实验室确诊轮状病毒粪便检测以及有记录的疫苗接种状态的儿童。我们按国家层面特征计算了轮状病毒VE。
纳入出生日期和监测医院就诊日期在3至59个月的儿童;其他变量在可用时进行标准化。如果儿童在到达前>14天接受了≥1剂轮状病毒疫苗,则被视为接种过疫苗。我们总结了儿童和国家层面的特征,包括全国5岁以下儿童死亡率(U5M)。按照制造商推荐的剂量方案,使用逻辑回归模型估计完整系列和部分系列调整后的VE。
我们纳入了6626名轮状病毒阳性儿童(病例)和19459名轮状病毒阴性儿童(对照)。与高U5M阶层内的所有组相比,低和中U5M阶层国家的儿童调整后的完整系列VE显著更高(74%(95%CI:64-81))(范围:52%(95%CI:42-60)至46%(95%CI:31-57))。部分系列低于完整系列估计值。
这些发现与已发表的文献一致,尽管它们表明在广泛的儿童死亡率水平内疫苗性能存在异质性。我们的发现还强调了完整系列疫苗接种的重要性。