Samanta Debopam
Division of Child Neurology, Department of Pediatrics, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR, USA.
Epilepsy Behav. 2025 Jan;162:110171. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2024.110171. Epub 2024 Nov 29.
Dravet syndrome (DS) is a severe genetic developmental and epileptic encephalopathy, primarily caused by SCN1A gene mutations. Historically, treatments like clobazam and valproate have been used without evidence from randomized controlled trials (RCTs). However, the therapeutic landscape of DS has evolved with multiple RCTs demonstrating the efficacy and safety of three antiseizure medications (ASMs): stiripentol, cannabidiol (CBD), and fenfluramine. In the absence of direct comparisons between these therapies, several network meta-analyses have been conducted to compare the ASMs, while expert consensus has independently been developed to formulate treatment guidelines. While these three ASMs show promise in reducing seizures, increasing awareness of non-seizure outcomes-such as cognitive development and quality of life-has shifted the focus of evaluation. Some recent real-world studies of these ASMs have reported improvements in these non-seizure outcomes, alongside sustained efficacy and safety. However, natural history studies continue to underscore persistent deficits in these areas and highlight suboptimal long-term seizure control despite the use of these therapies. This review addresses these gaps by first discussing network meta-analyses and treatment guidelines, along with the practical limitations of these approaches. It then examines the long-term efficacy, safety, non-seizure effects, and cost-effectiveness from real-world studies of these ASMs. Finally, emerging research on novel therapeutic approaches, including genetic and serotonergic modulation, is explored. By evaluating these developments, this review aims to guide clinical decision-making and propose future directions for optimizing DS care.
德拉韦综合征(DS)是一种严重的遗传性发育性癫痫性脑病,主要由SCN1A基因突变引起。从历史上看,氯巴占和丙戊酸盐等治疗方法在没有随机对照试验(RCT)证据的情况下就被使用。然而,随着多项RCT证明三种抗癫痫药物(ASM)——司替戊醇、大麻二酚(CBD)和芬氟拉明的疗效和安全性,DS的治疗格局发生了变化。在这些疗法之间缺乏直接比较的情况下,已经进行了几项网状Meta分析来比较这些ASM,同时独立制定了专家共识以制定治疗指南。虽然这三种ASM在减少癫痫发作方面显示出前景,但对非癫痫发作结果(如认知发展和生活质量)的认识提高,已经转移了评估重点。最近对这些ASM的一些真实世界研究报告了这些非癫痫发作结果的改善,以及持续的疗效和安全性。然而,自然史研究继续强调这些领域持续存在的缺陷,并突出了尽管使用了这些疗法,但长期癫痫控制仍不理想的情况。本综述通过首先讨论网状Meta分析和治疗指南以及这些方法的实际局限性来解决这些差距。然后,它研究了这些ASM真实世界研究的长期疗效、安全性、非癫痫发作影响和成本效益。最后,探讨了包括基因和血清素调节在内的新型治疗方法的新兴研究。通过评估这些进展,本综述旨在指导临床决策,并为优化DS护理提出未来方向。