El Yaagoubi Yacine, Lioret Eric, Thomas Clément, Loret Jean-Edouard, Simonneau Adrien, Amelot Aymeric, Michaud-Robert Anne-Victoire, Pasquesoone Henri, Philippe Laurent, Prunier-Aesch Caroline
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Vinci Clinic, Tours, France.
Department of Neurosurgery, Vinci Clinic, Tours, France.
Spine J. 2025 Apr;25(4):763-773. doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2024.11.013. Epub 2024 Nov 29.
Pseudarthrosis is a well-known cause of persistent or recurrent pain after anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF). Numerous radiographic criteria to determine the fusion status has been described in the literature, but their accuracies in clinical practice vary considerably and no 1 single method has proved superior. Fluorine-18 sodium fluoride (F-NaF) positron emission tomography/computed tomography (PET/CT), depicting osteoblastic activity, might be useful to identify pseudarthrosis after ACDF.
To investigate the ability of F-NaF PET/CT to identify pseudarthrosis after ACDF using surgical revision as the reference standard.
Retrospective observational study.
A total of 30 patients consisting of 40 surgical levels.
For each level, the presence or absence of intragraft uptake (InGU) and extragraft uptake (ExGU) were recorded, as well as adjacent segment uptake (ASU). CT part of the scan was rated as "fused" or "nonfused." Results were correlated to the gold-standard of revision surgery.
We retrospectively included consecutive patients who underwent revision surgery for suspicion of symptomatic pseudarthrosis after ACDF following F-NaF PET/CT performed between July 2019 and march 2023. F-NaF PET/CT results were compared with the gold standard of surgical evaluation of the stability of the fusion material. All patients underwent a systematic CT scan to evaluate the success of revision surgery 1 year postoperatively. We also investigated whether some patients underwent a repeated F-NaF PET/CT for persistent or recurrent pain after revision surgery.
Revision surgery demonstrated pseudarthrosis in 37 levels (93%) and excluded pseudarthrosis in 3 levels (7%). In the pseudarthrosis group (n=37), InGU was observed in all levels (100%) while ExGU was present in only 10 levels (27%). Fifteen levels (41%) with confirmed pseudarthrosis were rated as "fused" on CT scan preoperatively. In the nonpseudarthrosis group (n=3), InGU was observed in 2 levels (67%) while ExGU was never present. Two levels (67%) were rated as "fused" on fusion CT scan. One year postoperatively, fusion was successfully achieved on CT scan in 39 levels (98%). Seven patients (consisting of 8 levels) had been subsequently reexplored by F-NaF PET/CT for persistent or recurrent pain following revision surgery. PET/CT did not reveal any uptake (InGU or ExGU) in 7 levels, rated as "fused" on follow-up CT scan. PET/CT showed InGU in the only level rated as "nonfused" on CT scan.
F NaF PET/CT may be a useful adjunctive diagnostic tool to detect pseudarthrosis after ACDF surgery, especially in case of high clinical suspicion with standard conventional imaging not suggestive of nonunion. In our cohort, all levels (100%) with confirmed pseudarthrosis on revision surgery demonstrated InGU on PET/CT, while 41% of these levels were rated as "fused" on CT scan preoperatively. F NaF PET/CT might also be helpful after revision surgery to rule out repseudarthrosis and identify the pain generator. These promising data need to be confirmed in larger prospective studies.
假关节形成是颈椎前路椎间盘切除融合术(ACDF)后持续或反复疼痛的一个众所周知的原因。文献中描述了许多用于确定融合状态的影像学标准,但它们在临床实践中的准确性差异很大,没有一种单一方法被证明是 superior 的。氟 - 18 氟化钠(F - NaF)正电子发射断层扫描/计算机断层扫描(PET/CT)可描绘成骨细胞活性,可能有助于识别 ACDF 后的假关节形成。
以手术翻修为参考标准,研究 F - NaF PET/CT 识别 ACDF 后假关节形成的能力。
回顾性观察研究。
共 30 例患者,包含 40 个手术节段。
对于每个节段,记录移植物内摄取(InGU)和移植物外摄取(ExGU)的存在与否,以及相邻节段摄取(ASU)。扫描的 CT 部分被评为“融合”或“未融合”。结果与翻修手术的金标准相关。
我们回顾性纳入了 2019 年 7 月至 2023 年 3 月期间接受 F - NaF PET/CT 检查后因怀疑有症状性假关节形成而接受翻修手术的连续患者。将 F - NaF PET/CT 结果与融合材料稳定性的手术评估金标准进行比较。所有患者术后 1 年接受系统 CT 扫描以评估翻修手术的成功率。我们还调查了一些患者在翻修手术后是否因持续或反复疼痛而接受重复的 F - NaF PET/CT 检查。
翻修手术显示 37 个节段(93%)存在假关节形成,3 个节段(7%)排除假关节形成。在假关节形成组(n = 37)中,所有节段(100%)均观察到 InGU,而仅 10 个节段(27%)存在 ExGU。术前 CT 扫描将 15 个(41%)确诊为假关节形成的节段评为“融合”。在非假关节形成组(n = 3)中,2 个节段(67%)观察到 InGU,而从未出现 ExGU。2 个节段(67%)在融合 CT 扫描中被评为“融合”。术后 1 年,39 个节段(98%)的 CT 扫描显示融合成功。7 例患者(包含 8 个节段)在翻修手术后因持续或反复疼痛随后接受了 F - NaF PET/CT 再次检查。PET/CT 在 7 个节段未显示任何摄取(InGU 或 ExGU),这些节段在随访 CT 扫描中被评为“融合”。PET/CT 在 CT 扫描中唯一被评为“未融合”的节段显示有 InGU。
F - NaF PET/CT 可能是检测 ACDF 手术后假关节形成的一种有用的辅助诊断工具,尤其是在临床高度怀疑而标准传统影像学未提示骨不连的情况下。在我们的队列中,翻修手术确诊为假关节形成的所有节段(100%)在 PET/CT 上均显示 InGU,而这些节段中有 41%术前 CT 扫描被评为“融合”。F - NaF PET/CT 在翻修手术后也可能有助于排除再发假关节形成并识别疼痛源。这些有前景的数据需要在更大规模的前瞻性研究中得到证实。