Pokharel Himani Shree, Myia Salau Din, Chalise Anisha, Paudel Shishir
Department of Public Health, CiST College, Pokhara University, Kathmandu, Nepal.
Center for Research on Environment, Health and Population Activities (CREHPA), Lalitpur, Nepal.
PLoS One. 2024 Dec 2;19(12):e0314619. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0314619. eCollection 2024.
Transgender women are considered as one of the most vulnerable populations for commercial sex work and sexually transmitted infections. This mixed-method study aimed to explore the factors associated with commercial sex work among transgender women of Nepal along with their experience and the stigma associated with it.
A concurrent mixed-methods approach was employed in this cross-sectional study conducted from July to December 2022 in the Kathmandu Valley of Nepal. A total of 152 transgender women participated in the quantitative survey, and 17 of them were selected for in-depth interviews (IDIs). The chi-square test was employed at a 5% level of significance to identify factors associated with commercial sex work. Qualitative data from the IDIs were thematically analyzed, with key themes emerging around reasons for engaging in sex work and the stigma associated with it including the Silence, Shame, and Dignity & Treatment domains under sex work stigma.
Out of 152 transgender women, 104 (64%; 95% CI: 60.5-75.0%) were found to be currently working as a commercial sex worker. Factors such as education, household wealth, homelessness, history of sexual and verbal abuse, including rape and physical attacks, and socialization with others were found to have a statistically significant relation with commercial sex work at p<0.05. Despite engagement in commercial sex work, a higher proportion experienced sex work stigma under the Sex Work Stigma Scale.
The findings, derived from both quantitative and qualitative studies, emphasize the urgency of targeted interventions to alleviate the challenges faced by this marginalized population. The observed higher proportion of commercial sex work and sex work stigma underscores the pervasive social challenges of transgender women. A comprehensive and coordinated effort is essential, bringing together governmental, private sector, and public awareness initiatives to effectively manage stigma and address the underlying causes of commercial sex work.
跨性别女性被认为是商业性工作和性传播感染的最脆弱群体之一。这项混合方法研究旨在探讨尼泊尔跨性别女性中与商业性工作相关的因素,以及她们的经历和与之相关的耻辱感。
在2022年7月至12月于尼泊尔加德满都谷地进行的这项横断面研究中,采用了同步混合方法。共有152名跨性别女性参与了定量调查,其中17人被选入进行深入访谈(IDI)。采用卡方检验,显著性水平为5%,以确定与商业性工作相关的因素。对深入访谈的定性数据进行了主题分析,围绕从事性工作的原因和与之相关的耻辱感出现了关键主题,包括性工作耻辱感下的沉默、羞耻、尊严与待遇领域。
在152名跨性别女性中,有104人(64%;95%可信区间:60.5 - 75.0%)目前从事商业性工作。发现教育、家庭财富、无家可归、性虐待和言语虐待史(包括强奸和身体攻击)以及与他人的社交等因素与商业性工作在p<0.05时有统计学显著关系。尽管从事商业性工作,但在性工作耻辱感量表下,较高比例的人经历了性工作耻辱感。
定量和定性研究得出的结果强调了针对性干预措施的紧迫性,以缓解这一边缘化群体面临的挑战。观察到的较高比例的商业性工作和性工作耻辱感凸显了跨性别女性普遍面临的社会挑战。全面协调的努力至关重要,需要政府、私营部门和公众意识倡议共同合作,以有效管理耻辱感并解决商业性工作的根本原因。