Johnson Rebecca A, Simko Tyler, Imai Kosuke
McCourt School of Public Policy, Department of Sociology, Georgetown University, Washington, DC 20001.
Department of Politics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 Dec 10;121(50):e2404924121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2404924121. Epub 2024 Dec 3.
A large body of research documents the barriers faced by first-generation, low-income (FGLI) students as "hidden minorities" on elite college campuses. Although existing studies show brief psychological interventions can help mitigate some of these obstacles, universities are investing in more intensive interventions that try to both shift mindsets and mitigate structural disadvantages in FGLI students' academic preparation. In collaboration with the administrators at a highly selective university, we conducted a randomized controlled trial of a summer bridge program targeted at FGLI students. During summers between 2017 and 2019, we randomly selected 232 out of 418 first-generation or low-income students and invited them to attend an intensive, six-week-long residential summer program featuring courses for academic credit. Students randomized to the control group either interacted with online content offering no academic credit or had no summer intervention. Our preregistered analysis shows that the program encouraged FGLI students to pursue a more ambitious first-year program, increasing the proportion of nonintroductory courses by 7 percentage points. The program also increased the proportion of courses taken for a grade rather than as pass-fail by 6 percentage points. These improvements were accompanied by no discernible impact on first-year grade point averages (GPAs) and academic withdrawal. The findings show the potential to academically integrate FGLI students into selective university communities.
大量研究记录了第一代低收入(FGLI)学生作为精英大学校园里的“隐藏少数群体”所面临的障碍。尽管现有研究表明,简短的心理干预有助于缓解其中一些障碍,但大学正在投入更多强化干预措施,试图改变思维模式,并缓解FGLI学生在学业准备方面的结构性劣势。我们与一所高选拔性大学的管理人员合作,针对FGLI学生开展了一项暑期衔接课程的随机对照试验。在2017年至2019年的夏季,我们从418名第一代或低收入学生中随机挑选了232名,并邀请他们参加一个为期六周的强化住宿暑期课程,该课程提供可获得学分的课程。被随机分配到对照组的学生要么与不提供学分的在线内容互动,要么没有暑期干预。我们预先登记的分析表明,该课程鼓励FGLI学生选择更具挑战性的一年级课程计划,将非入门课程的比例提高了7个百分点。该课程还将以计分制而非及格/不及格制修读的课程比例提高了6个百分点。这些进步伴随着对一年级平均绩点(GPA)和学业退学率没有明显影响。研究结果显示了将FGLI学生在学业上融入选拔性大学社区的潜力。