Obayemi Joy E, Shaw Brian I, Greenberg Goni-Katz, Henson Jackie, McElroy Lisa M
Department of Surgery, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan.
Northwestern University, Comprehensive Transplant Center, Chicago, Illinois.
Curr Opin Organ Transplant. 2025 Feb 1;30(1):37-45. doi: 10.1097/MOT.0000000000001191. Epub 2024 Dec 4.
This review summarizes the different instruments for evaluating the psychosocial health of transplant candidates, the evidence demonstrating how these instruments relate to probability of transplant waitlisting and transplant outcomes, and the critical knowledge gaps that exist in the causal pathway between psychosocial health and clinical transplant trajectory.
The current literature reveals that psychosocial assessments are a common reason for racial and ethnic minorities to be denied access to the transplant list. Given evidence that a lack of clinician consensus exists regarding the definition of, importance of, and reproducibility of psychosocial support evaluations, this facet of the holistic evaluation process may create a unique challenge for already vulnerable patient populations. Though recent evidence shows that psychosocial evaluation scores predict select transplant outcomes, these findings remain inconsistent.
Multiple instruments for psychosocial transplant evaluation exist, though the utility of these instruments remains uncertain. As equity becomes an increasingly urgent priority for the transplant system, rigorous interrogation of the causal pathway between psychosocial health and transplant longevity is still needed.
本综述总结了评估移植候选者心理社会健康状况的不同工具,证明这些工具与列入移植等待名单的可能性及移植结果之间关系的证据,以及心理社会健康与临床移植轨迹之间因果途径中存在的关键知识空白。
当前文献表明,心理社会评估是少数族裔被拒绝列入移植名单的常见原因。鉴于有证据表明临床医生在心理社会支持评估的定义、重要性和可重复性方面缺乏共识,整体评估过程的这一方面可能给本就脆弱的患者群体带来独特挑战。尽管最近的证据显示心理社会评估分数可预测某些移植结果,但这些发现仍不一致。
存在多种用于心理社会移植评估的工具,但其效用仍不确定。随着公平性成为移植系统日益紧迫的优先事项,仍需对心理社会健康与移植寿命之间的因果途径进行严格审视。