Welner Michael, DeLisi Matt, Janusewski Theresa
The Forensic Panel, West Palm Beach, Florida, USA.
Mt. Sinai School of Medicine, Mount Sinai, New York City, New York, USA.
Behav Sci Law. 2025 Mar-Apr;43(2):185-202. doi: 10.1002/bsl.2707. Epub 2024 Dec 4.
Confessions are an important evidentiary part of the legal process, and false confessions have been notable contributors to wrongful convictions. However, academic research in the psychology and law field primarily relies on student or volunteer samples in staged exercises, methodological features that lack ecological validity for replicating police interrogation or the pressures distinctive to high stakes crime investigations. Here, we provide an integrative review of research and data on false confessions during police interrogations with distinctions of key concepts, relevant case law pertaining to confessions including several U.S. Supreme Court decisions, updating the typology of false confessions, the quantification of false confessions, risk factors for false confessions, interrogation risk factors for false confessions, validity threats to false confessions research, and recommended directions for informing courts and the law.
口供是法律程序中重要的证据部分,而虚假口供一直是导致错误定罪的显著因素。然而,心理学与法学领域的学术研究主要依赖于在模拟情境中使用学生或志愿者样本,这些方法学特征在复制警方审讯或高风险犯罪调查所特有的压力方面缺乏生态效度。在此,我们对警方审讯期间虚假口供的研究和数据进行综合综述,区分关键概念、与口供相关的判例法(包括美国最高法院的几项裁决),更新虚假口供的类型、虚假口供的量化、虚假口供的风险因素、虚假口供的审讯风险因素、虚假口供研究的效度威胁,以及为法院和法律提供参考的推荐方向。