Al-Haideri Rulla, Weiss Adam, Ismail Karim
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Carleton University, 1125 Colonel By Dr, Ottawa, ON K1S 5B6, Canada.
Accid Anal Prev. 2025 Mar;211:107850. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2024.107850. Epub 2024 Dec 5.
Conflicts between cyclists and motorized vehicles at crosswalks often lead to severe collisions. The varied behaviour of cyclists at these crossings introduces unobserved heterogeneity. Despite this, there is a notable research gap in studying the cyclist behaviour at roundabout crosswalks. To address this gap, we propose a discrete choice latent class method to capture the multi-level latent heterogeneity in cyclists' crossing behaviour at roundabout crosswalks. Latent heterogeneity can be captured at multiple levels: site-level, interaction-level, choice-attribute level, and individual-level. This method, rooted in behavioural theory, aims to provide a deeper understanding of cyclists' crossing decisions, enhancing safety measures at these intersections. We present an application of the proposed method to two publicly available drone datasets of naturalistic road user trajectories at roundabouts, including 8 roundabout sites that exhibit some level of similarity to minimize site heterogeneity. We capture the latent heterogeneity in the cyclists' membership to a distinct behavioural class at two levels using these datasets: the individual level, represented by the speed of the cyclist as they enter the crosswalk, and the interaction level, defined by the presence of vehicles approaching the cyclist. Our findings align with previous studies that emphasize the significance of the initial speed variable in influencing cyclists' subsequent behaviour and decisions. We identified two distinct classes of cyclists. We hypothesize that Class 1 cyclists, whom we refer to as passers, tend to bypass or overtake other road users at the crosswalk, especially in the absence of vehicles, prioritizing speed and efficiency. We also hypothesize that Class 2 cyclists, referred to as followers, exhibit more cautious behaviour, preferring to maintain a steady pace and avoid overtaking, particularly when vehicles are present. The proposed latent class model effectively captures this behavioural distinction, offering a more granular view of cyclists' decision-making processes at roundabout crosswalks. A key finding is that the discrete choice model with a latent class structure outperforms the basic model without it, despite having more degrees of freedom, as it achieves a lower BIC and AIC but improved model fit statistic. This demonstrates that latent heterogeneity can be effectively captured, leading to improved predictions and outperforming the basic non-latent class model. Classifying cyclists into distinct behavioural classes not only enhances cyclist safety at crosswalks but also provides valuable insights for the development of autonomous vehicle-cyclist interactions.
自行车骑行者与机动车在人行横道处发生的冲突常常导致严重碰撞。骑行者在这些路口的行为各异,这带来了未被观察到的异质性。尽管如此,在研究环形交叉路口人行横道上骑行者的行为方面,仍存在显著的研究空白。为填补这一空白,我们提出一种离散选择潜在类别方法,以捕捉环形交叉路口人行横道上骑行者过街行为中的多层次潜在异质性。潜在异质性可在多个层面被捕捉:地点层面、交互层面、选择属性层面和个体层面。该方法基于行为理论,旨在更深入地理解骑行者的过街决策,加强这些路口的安全措施。我们将所提方法应用于两个公开可用的环形交叉路口自然道路使用者轨迹的无人机数据集,其中包括8个具有一定相似性的环形交叉路口地点,以尽量减少地点异质性。我们利用这些数据集在两个层面捕捉骑行者归属于不同行为类别的潜在异质性:个体层面,以骑行者进入人行横道时的速度表示;交互层面,由接近骑行者的车辆的存在来定义。我们的研究结果与之前强调初始速度变量在影响骑行者后续行为和决策方面的重要性的研究一致。我们识别出两类不同的骑行者。我们假设第1类骑行者,即我们所说的“穿行者”,倾向于在人行横道处绕过或超过其他道路使用者,尤其是在没有车辆的情况下,将速度和效率置于首位。我们还假设第2类骑行者,即“跟随者”,表现出更谨慎的行为,更喜欢保持稳定的速度并避免超车,特别是在有车辆出现时。所提的潜在类别模型有效地捕捉了这种行为差异,为环形交叉路口人行横道上骑行者的决策过程提供了更细致的视角。一个关键发现是,具有潜在类别结构的离散选择模型尽管自由度更高,但优于没有该结构的基本模型,因为它实现了更低的贝叶斯信息准则(BIC)和赤池信息准则(AIC),且模型拟合统计量有所改善。这表明潜在异质性能够被有效捕捉,从而带来更好的预测效果,并且优于基本的非潜在类别模型。将骑行者分类为不同的行为类别不仅能提高人行横道上骑行者的安全性,还为自动驾驶车辆与骑行者交互的发展提供了有价值的见解。