Androni Alexandra, Fleer Joke, Smids Laura R, van der Wouden Joke M, Jaarsma A Debbie C, Schönrock-Adema Johanna
University of Groningen and University Medical Center Groningen, Wenckebach Institute for Education and Training, Lifelong Learning, Education and Assessment Research Network (LEARN), Groningen, The Netherlands.
University of Groningen and University Medical Center Groningen, Department of Health Psychology, Groningen, The Netherlands.
Perspect Med Educ. 2024 Dec 5;13(1):608-619. doi: 10.5334/pme.1414. eCollection 2024.
In this study we aimed to identify behaviours representative of agentic engagement in pre-clinical medical education problem-based learning (PBL) groups. Agentic engagement is defined as the proactive, intentional contributions students make to their flow of instruction. This concept, developed in secondary education, appears relevant for benefitting optimally from PBL in higher medical education.
We followed a four-step process to identify any behaviours representative of agentic engagement in our PBL setting. Following a literature search on agentic engagement scales, proactive behaviour, PBL practices and adult learning, we listed behaviours that could denote agentic engagement in our context. We fine-tuned this list through exploratory observations and tailored it to our specific context of second-year PBL groups.
We identified ten observable student behaviours representative of agentic engagement within medical PBL groups. Some aligned with previous literature (asking questions, telling the teacher what they (dis)like, telling the teacher what they are interested in, defending opinions, expressing expectations, suggesting co-operation), and others had not been identified before as representative of agentic engagement (making learning as interactive as possible, creating alternative ways of covering the material, correcting content and enriching others' insights); thereby introducing novel behaviours unique to our setting.
In medical PBL groups, we identified both known agentic engagement behaviours and distinctive behaviours specific to our context, thereby highlighting that the expression of agentic engagement is context-bound.
在本研究中,我们旨在确定临床前医学教育基于问题的学习(PBL)小组中具有能动参与代表性的行为。能动参与被定义为学生对其学习流程做出的主动、有意的贡献。这一在中等教育中发展起来的概念,似乎与在高等医学教育中从PBL中获得最佳收益相关。
我们遵循了一个四步流程来确定在我们的PBL环境中具有能动参与代表性的任何行为。在对能动参与量表、主动行为、PBL实践和成人学习进行文献检索后,我们列出了在我们的背景下可能表示能动参与的行为。我们通过探索性观察对这份清单进行了微调,并使其适用于我们二年级PBL小组的特定背景。
我们确定了医学PBL小组中具有能动参与代表性的十种可观察到的学生行为。其中一些与先前的文献一致(提问、告诉老师他们喜欢或不喜欢什么、告诉老师他们感兴趣的事情、捍卫观点、表达期望、建议合作),而其他行为以前未被确定为能动参与的代表(使学习尽可能具有互动性、创造涵盖材料的替代方法、纠正内容并丰富他人的见解);从而引入了我们环境中独有的新行为。
在医学PBL小组中,我们既确定了已知的能动参与行为,也确定了特定于我们背景的独特行为,从而突出表明能动参与的表现是受背景限制的。