Prostate puzzle: Unconventional prostatic STUMP findings in a middle-aged patient prompt closer examination.

A 41-year-old male presented with obstructive urinary symptoms and an enlarged prostate. Subsequent testing revealed a remarkably high PSA level of 150 ng/mL, considerably above normal limits, raising concern for possible malignancy. Transrectal ultrasound showed an enlarged heterogeneous prostate measuring 74×80×75mm. PSMA PET/CT detected intense tracer uptake. While MRI and biopsy ruled out carcinoma, they indicated Stromal Tumors of Uncertain Malignant Potential (STUMP), an uncommon diagnosis in younger patients. This complex case highlights the essential role of advanced multimodal imaging and immunohistochemistry in diagnosing atypical prostatic lesions of uncertain malignant potential like STUMP, given their histologic similarity to benign conditions posing diagnostic difficulties. A multidisciplinary approach led to the STUMP diagnosis and decision for long-term monitoring instead of radical prostatectomy due to STUMP's unpredictable behavior. This report reinforces the need for diligence when evaluating seemingly benign but diagnostically challenging presentations that could conceal conditions like STUMP, and the importance of a multidisciplinary approach for accurate diagnosis and management of such rare prostatic proliferations.