McDonnell Charlotte, Devine Michael, Kavanagh Dara
School of Medicine, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, 123 St.Stephen's Green, Dublin, Ireland.
Department of Surgical Affairs, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland, 121 St. Stephen's Green, Dublin, Ireland.
Surgeon. 2025 Apr;23(2):e49-e62. doi: 10.1016/j.surge.2024.12.001. Epub 2024 Dec 9.
Robotic surgery is typically characterized by the telemanipulation of robotic arms controlled by a surgeon via a command system. Medical technology advancements have caused variations in how robotic surgery is conceptualised. It is important to ascertain the public's perception of robotic surgery, as this impacts decision making.
A study protocol was developed in accordance with the PRISMA guidelines. All original research articles, abstracts, conference proceedings or grey literature were eligible. The Medline (Pubmed), Scopus, and Cochrane Databases, Google Scholar, white and green statement papers, and international guidelines were searched. A preliminary search identified key terms. Title and abstract screening was conducted. Full texts were appraised for eligibility. An inductive extraction process was utilized, grouping data into themes by content analysis, and developing a coding framework. Heterogeneity limited pooling of data and prevented aggregated data analysis. Therefore, NVivo software was used to augment this qualitative process and develop a meta-synthesis.
The search yielded 8818 articles across the bibliographic databases. After inclusion of the grey literature 132 full text manuscripts were assessed. 35 of which were included. Three main themes were identified from the coding framework: understanding of robotic surgery, acceptance of robotic surgery, and perceptions of robotic surgery. Micro-construct subthemes included 'understanding of robotic autonomy, surgeon role, and outcomes', 'determinants of understanding', 'sources of information', 'intention to use', and 'determinants of acceptance'. Robotic surgery is perceived as a risky modality by the general public. They have a limited understanding of this surgical approach and the extent of autonomy a robotic system has. Sex, age, and residence are important factors effecting the degree of understanding and intention to undergo robotic surgery.
Robotic surgery is perceived as a risky procedure by the general public. They have limited understanding of the modality, and low rates of acceptance to undergo it fearing greater complications.
机器人手术的典型特征是由外科医生通过指令系统对机器人手臂进行远程操作。医疗技术的进步使得人们对机器人手术的概念化方式产生了差异。确定公众对机器人手术的看法非常重要,因为这会影响决策。
根据PRISMA指南制定了一项研究方案。所有原创研究文章、摘要、会议论文或灰色文献均符合条件。检索了Medline(PubMed)、Scopus和Cochrane数据库、谷歌学术、白皮书和绿皮书声明文件以及国际指南。进行了初步搜索以确定关键词。对标题和摘要进行筛选。对全文进行合格性评估。采用归纳提取过程,通过内容分析将数据分组为主题,并开发了一个编码框架。异质性限制了数据的合并,无法进行汇总数据分析。因此,使用NVivo软件来增强这一定性过程并进行元综合分析。
在各个书目数据库中检索到8818篇文章。纳入灰色文献后,评估了132篇全文手稿。其中35篇被纳入。从编码框架中确定了三个主要主题:对机器人手术的理解、对机器人手术的接受度以及对机器人手术的看法。微观构建子主题包括“对机器人自主性、外科医生角色和结果的理解”、“理解的决定因素”、“信息来源”、“使用意图”以及“接受的决定因素”。普通公众认为机器人手术是一种有风险的方式。他们对这种手术方法以及机器人系统的自主程度了解有限。性别、年龄和居住地是影响对机器人手术的理解程度和接受手术意愿的重要因素。
普通公众认为机器人手术是一种有风险的手术。他们对这种手术方式了解有限,由于担心并发症更多,接受手术的比例较低。