Gao Xiang, Han Peng, Zong Yiping, Wang Zijie, Zhang Wei, Lu Pei
Department of Urology, The Second Affiliated Hospital of Nanjing Medical University, Nanjing, China.
Department of Urology, The First Affiliated Hospital of Nanjing Medical University, Nanjing, China.
Front Surg. 2024 Nov 27;11:1489397. doi: 10.3389/fsurg.2024.1489397. eCollection 2024.
At present, there is no effective drug to remove residual stones. Total flavonoids of desmodium styracifolium (TFDS) is an innovative traditional Chinese medicine listed in 2022, which can be used to treat ureteral calculi. This study was to explore the effectiveness and economic value of TFDS in the treatment of residual stones after flexible ureteroscopic lithotripsy (FURL).
A total of 161 patients who underwent unilateral ureteroscopic lithotripsy for urinary calculi by the same surgeon in our center from May 2022 to February 2024 were retrospectively included. According to the use of stone-removal drugs after operation, patients were divided into TFDS group and Control group. The residual stones showed by x-ray plain film when the double J tube was removed were compared between the two groups, and the economic benefits of TFDS were analyzed by cost-benefit analysis.
The data of 161 patients were collected, including 80 cases in TFDS group and 81 cases in Control group. The SFR rates at the endpoint of follow-up in TFDS group and Control group were 98.75% and 88.88%, respectively. In the subgroup analysis of post-operative residual stones, the stone clearance rate of TFDS was higher (47.62% vs. 18.18%). No obvious adverse events were reported in two groups. The cost/benefit ratio of TFDS was lower (20.43 vs. 32.57). Cost of TFDS was increased by ¥12.97 for each additional unit of total effective rate.
The combination of dusting FURL and TFDS can effectively remove the urolithiasis when compared to only FURL, which showed highly economic benefits.
目前,尚无有效药物可清除残留结石。广金钱草总黄酮(TFDS)是2022年上市的创新型中药,可用于治疗输尿管结石。本研究旨在探讨TFDS在治疗输尿管软镜碎石术(FURL)后残留结石中的有效性和经济价值。
回顾性纳入2022年5月至2024年2月在本中心由同一位外科医生行单侧输尿管镜取石术治疗尿路结石的161例患者。根据术后是否使用排石药物,将患者分为TFDS组和对照组。比较两组拔除双J管时X线平片显示的残留结石情况,并通过成本效益分析评估TFDS的经济效益。
收集161例患者的数据,其中TFDS组80例,对照组81例。TFDS组和对照组随访终点的结石清除率分别为98.75%和88.88%。在术后残留结石亚组分析中,TFDS组的结石清除率更高(47.62%对18.18%)。两组均未报告明显不良事件。TFDS的成本效益比更低(20.43对32.57)。总有效率每增加1个单位,TFDS成本增加12.97元。
与单纯FURL相比,FURL联合TFDS能有效清除尿路结石,具有较高的经济效益。