Draper Brian, Wijeratne Chanaka
Discipline of Psychiatry and Mental Health, University of NSW, Sydney, AU -NSW, Australia.
Australas Psychiatry. 2025 Jun;33(3):481-485. doi: 10.1177/10398562241306899. Epub 2024 Dec 12.
AimsTo identify clinical and other factors associated with the use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in New South Wales for the period 1944-1949 and to compare with contemporaneous practice.MethodAnnual reports of the Inspector-General of Mental Hospitals in NSW (1944/45 to 1948/49) were examined.Main findingsSeven hospitals reported a total of 8964 courses of treatment during the period. Demographically, 60.6% of patients who received ECT were female, and rural hospitals reported 13.6% of courses. ECT was as likely to be given for non-affective psychoses (37.7%), as for affective psychoses (35.0%). ECT was also administered for confusional states and non-psychotic disorders. Better outcomes were observed for depression, anxiety and confusional states than non-affective psychoses. Recovery rates declined over the study period. Mortality was <1%.ConclusionsThe clinical indications for ECT in the mid-twentieth century in NSW were much broader than currently. There has been no change in the sex ratio of patients administered ECT or reported mortality.
确定1944年至1949年期间新南威尔士州使用电休克疗法(ECT)的临床及其他相关因素,并与同期的治疗实践进行比较。
查阅新南威尔士州精神病院监察长的年度报告(1944/45至1948/49)。
在此期间,七家医院共报告了8964个疗程的治疗。从人口统计学角度看,接受ECT治疗的患者中60.6%为女性,农村医院报告的疗程占13.6%。ECT用于非情感性精神病的比例(37.7%)与情感性精神病的比例(35.0%)相近。ECT也用于意识模糊状态和非精神病性障碍。与非情感性精神病相比,抑郁症、焦虑症和意识模糊状态的治疗效果更佳。在研究期间,康复率有所下降。死亡率低于1%。
20世纪中叶新南威尔士州ECT的临床适应症比目前广泛得多。接受ECT治疗的患者性别比例及报告的死亡率均无变化。