van Bavel Bianca, Berrang-Ford Lea, Moon Kelly, Gudda Fredrick, Thornton Alexander J, Robinson Rufus F S, King Rebecca
Priestley Centre for Climate Futures, School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK; School of Health Sciences, Insight SFI Research Centre for Data Analytics, University of Galway, Galway, Ireland.
Priestley Centre for Climate Futures, School of Earth and Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK; Centre for Climate and Health Security, UK Health Security Agency, London, UK.
Lancet Planet Health. 2024 Dec;8(12):e1118-e1128. doi: 10.1016/S2542-5196(24)00273-0.
Climate change and antimicrobial resistance (AMR) present crucial challenges for the health and wellbeing of people, animals, plants, and ecosystems worldwide, yet the two are largely treated as separate and unrelated challenges. The aim of this systematic scoping Review is to understand the nature of the growing evidence base linking AMR and climate change and to identify knowledge gaps and areas for further research. We conducted a systematic search of the peer-reviewed literature in Scopus, Web of Science, and PubMed on 27 June, 2022. Our search strategy identified and screened 1687 unique results. Data were extracted and analysed from 574 records meeting our inclusion criteria. 222 (39%) of these reviewed articles discussed harmful synergies in which both climate change and AMR exist independently and can interact synergistically, resulting in negative outcomes. Just over a quarter (n=163; 28%) of the literature contained general or broad references to AMR and climate change, whereas a fifth (n=111; 19%) of articles referred to climate change influencing the emergence and evolution of AMR. 12% of articles (n=70) presented positive synergies between approaches aimed at addressing climate change and interventions targeting the management and control of AMR. The remaining literature focused on the shared drivers of AMR and climate change, the trade-offs between climate actions that have unanticipated negative outcomes for AMR (or vice versa), and, finally, the pathways through which AMR can negatively influence climate change. Our findings indicate multiple intersections through which climate change and AMR can and do connect. Research in this area is still nascent, disciplinarily isolated, and only beginning to converge, with few documents primarily focused on the equal intersection of both topics. Greater empirical and evidence-based attention is needed to investigate knowledge gaps related to specific climate change hazards and antimicrobial resistant fungi, helminths, protists, and viruses.
气候变化和抗菌药物耐药性(AMR)对全球人类、动物、植物和生态系统的健康与福祉构成了严峻挑战,但这两者在很大程度上被视为相互独立且不相关的挑战。本系统综述的目的是了解将AMR与气候变化联系起来的不断增长的证据基础的性质,并确定知识空白和进一步研究的领域。我们于2022年6月27日在Scopus、科学网和PubMed上对同行评审文献进行了系统检索。我们的检索策略识别并筛选出1687条独特结果。从符合我们纳入标准的574条记录中提取并分析了数据。这些综述文章中有222篇(39%)讨论了有害协同作用,即气候变化和AMR各自独立存在且能产生协同相互作用,从而导致负面结果。略超过四分之一(n = 163;28%)的文献包含对AMR和气候变化的一般性或宽泛提及,而五分之一(n = 111;19%)的文章提到气候变化影响AMR的出现和演变。12%的文章(n = 70)介绍了应对气候变化的方法与针对AMR管理和控制的干预措施之间的积极协同作用。其余文献关注AMR和气候变化的共同驱动因素、对AMR有意外负面结果的气候行动之间的权衡(反之亦然),以及最后,AMR可能对气候变化产生负面影响的途径。我们的研究结果表明,气候变化和AMR能够且确实存在多个相互关联之处。该领域的研究仍处于初期阶段,学科孤立且才刚刚开始融合,主要聚焦于这两个主题平等交叉点的文献很少。需要更多基于实证和证据的关注来调查与特定气候变化危害以及抗微生物真菌、蠕虫、原生生物和病毒相关的知识空白。