Grassi Tiziana, Tiple Dorina, Villa Marika, Grisetti Tiziana, Pricci Flavia, Floridia Marco, Giuliano Marina, Castriotta Luigi, Rosolen Valentina, Beorchia Yvonne, Fanizza Caterina, Bisceglia Lucia, Francesconi Paolo, Profili Francesco, Bonaccorsi Guglielmo, Bruschi Mario, Onder Graziano
Dipartimento Malattie di Cardiovascolari, Endocrino-Metaboliche e Invecchiamento, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Roma.
Dipartimento di Neuroscienze, Istituto Superiore di Sanità, Roma.
Epidemiol Prev. 2024 Nov-Dec;48(6):438-448. doi: 10.19191/EP24.6.A786.135.
the long-COVID condition is gaining increasing relevance in terms of public health, but few studies have evaluated its impact on use of healthcare resources and the organizational responses of healthcare systems. Although many studies have evaluated case studies of individuals with long-COVID, the clinical spectrum of symptoms is still poorly defined due to the heterogeneity of the populations studied, the variability of the definitions used, and the absence of disease markers. In this context, in 2022, a project was designed and implemented in cooperation between the National Centre for Prevention and Control of the Italian Ministry of Health and the Italian National Health Institute (Istituto Superiore di Sanità, ISS).
this project was articulated into five main objectives: 1. definition of the health care dimensions of the long-COVID phenomenon. This objective included an analysis of regional data flows to measure use of hospitalization services (acute, rehabilitation, long-term care), resource consumption (specialist visits and drug consumption), and the rate of institutionalization in patients with a history of COVID-19; 2. definition of number, characteristics, and distribution of long-COVID centres across the national territory. This objective has been implemented through a national survey of long-COVID diagnosis and assistance centres; 3. definition of clinical good practices about the management of long-COVID condition by a multidisciplinary group of experts; 4. definition of a long-COVID surveillance system; including the definition of a specific data set of information and the identification of a sample of clinical centres that deal with the care of subjects with long-term effects of COVID-19 and the setup of a dedicated online platform; a phone survey based on more than 1,000 interviews assessed the spectrum of symptoms reported; 5. structuring a national network and providing information, which included networking of the centres participating in the study with the dissemination of periodic information and update workshops or webinars; the creation of a website dedicated to the long-COVID condition, with general information for citizens and a section dedicated to the project; training activities.
Objective 1: a cohort study of over 600,000 individuals showed that people exposed to SARS-CoV-2 infection, particularly those who were hospitalized, appear to use more healthcare resources in the 6 months following infection than those who were not exposed. Individuals hospitalized in intensive care showed rates of outpatient visits 3 times higher than those who were not exposed and over 4 times higher rates for diagnostic imaging tests and hospitalizations. The case-control study found an increased risk of initiating antidepressant therapy among individuals exposed to SARS-CoV-2 infection compared to those who were not exposed, particularly among those who were hospitalized during acute infection. Furthermore, COVID-19 vaccination may play a protective role in this context. Objective 2: 124 clinical centres completed the questionnaire developed to define the patterns of clinical care for patients with long-COVID. Most centres provided care through outpatient visits or day hospital services with scheduled visits or referral to primary care and had specialist skills that allowed a multidisciplinary approach to the subject with suspected long-COVID condition. Objective 3: a multidisciplinary team, representative of the multi-systemic nature of long-COVID, with the participation of 16 experts, developed recommendations for the management of patients with long-COVID, based on current knowledge on the topic, with the aim of contributing to standardizing the activities of clinical centres throughout Italy. Objective 4: the clinical surveillance system has allowed the collection of data from over 1,200 patients from 30 clinical centres for the definition of symptom, their aggregation in clusters, and associated factors. Information on symptom profile was also assessed through a phone survey of more than 1,000 participants. Objective 5: the ISS website on long COVID provided information on the long-COVID condition and illustrated the CCM project, with links to webinars and workshops. In addition, a FAD course - entitled 'long-COVID: a new clinical scenario' - was implemented on the EDU-ISS platform, with over 14,000 participants.
the results of this study show that long-COVID is a frequent condition in our country, which, due to the amplitude of numbers and the spectrum of symptoms, has a substantial impact on resource consumption. This demonstrates that it will be necessary to implement, guarantee and monitor well-defined care standards for this condition.
长期新冠状况在公共卫生方面的相关性日益增加,但很少有研究评估其对医疗资源使用和医疗系统组织应对措施的影响。尽管许多研究评估了长期新冠患者的个案研究,但由于所研究人群的异质性、所用定义的可变性以及缺乏疾病标志物,症状的临床谱仍定义不清。在此背景下,2022年,意大利卫生部国家预防与控制中心与意大利国家卫生研究院(ISS)合作设计并实施了一个项目。
该项目分为五个主要目标:1. 定义长期新冠现象的医疗维度。该目标包括分析区域数据流,以衡量住院服务(急性、康复、长期护理)的使用情况、资源消耗(专科就诊和药物消耗)以及新冠病史患者的机构化率;2. 确定全国长期新冠中心的数量、特征和分布。该目标通过对长期新冠诊断和援助中心的全国性调查得以实现;3. 由多学科专家小组定义长期新冠状况管理的临床良好实践;4. 定义长期新冠监测系统;包括定义特定的信息数据集,确定处理新冠长期影响患者护理的临床中心样本,并建立专用在线平台;基于1000多次访谈的电话调查评估了报告的症状谱;5. 构建国家网络并提供信息,其中包括参与研究的中心联网,定期发布信息以及举办更新研讨会或网络研讨会;创建一个专门针对长期新冠状况的网站,为公民提供一般信息以及一个专门介绍该项目的板块;开展培训活动。
目标1:一项对60多万人的队列研究表明,接触过新冠病毒感染的人,尤其是那些住院的人,在感染后的6个月内似乎比未接触过的人使用更多的医疗资源。在重症监护病房住院的人门诊就诊率比未接触者高3倍,诊断成像检查和住院率高出4倍多。病例对照研究发现,与未接触者相比,接触过新冠病毒感染的人开始使用抗抑郁药治疗的风险增加,尤其是在急性感染期间住院的人。此外,在这种情况下,新冠疫苗接种可能起到保护作用。目标2:124个临床中心完成了为定义长期新冠患者临床护理模式而制定的问卷。大多数中心通过门诊就诊或日间医院服务提供护理,安排定期就诊或转诊至初级保健,并具备专业技能,能够对疑似长期新冠状况的患者采取多学科方法。目标3:一个代表长期新冠多系统性质的多学科团队,有16名专家参与,根据该主题的现有知识为长期新冠患者的管理制定了建议, 旨在促进意大利各地临床中心活动的标准化。目标4:临床监测系统已从30个临床中心的1200多名患者那里收集了数据,用于定义症状、将其聚类以及相关因素。还通过对1000多名参与者的电话调查评估了症状概况信息。目标5:ISS关于长期新冠的网站提供了有关长期新冠状况的信息,并介绍了CCM项目,还提供了网络研讨会和工作坊的链接。此外,在EDU - ISS平台上实施了一门名为“长期新冠:一种新的临床情况”的FAD课程,有超过14000名参与者。
本研究结果表明,长期新冠在我国是一种常见状况,由于其数量规模和症状谱,对资源消耗有重大影响。这表明有必要针对这种状况实施、保障并监测明确的护理标准。