Kaić Ana, Luštrek Barbara, Žgur Silvester, Potočnik Klemen
Department of Animal Science and Technology, Faculty of Agriculture, University of Zagreb, Svetošimunska 25, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia.
Department of Animal Science, Biotechnical Faculty, University of Ljubljana, Jamnikarjeva 101, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Animals (Basel). 2024 Dec 7;14(23):3540. doi: 10.3390/ani14233540.
This study investigated whether the suspension method (tenderstretch, TS or Achilles tendon, AT) can improve the quality of horsemeat by analyzing longissimus dorsi (LD) and semitendinosus (ST) muscles. A total of 25 horse carcasses were considered experimental units and split longitudinally, with one half suspended using the TS method and the other half using the AT method, which enabled a direct comparison within the carcass. After 7 days of aging under commercial processing conditions, the LD and ST muscles were analyzed for pH, color (L*, a*, b*), water-holding capacity (drip loss, thawing loss, cooking loss), tenderness (Warner-Bratzler shear force), and sarcomere length. Statistical analysis was performed using the MIXED procedure in SAS, with Bonferroni correction applied for post hoc comparisons. Significant differences were found between the muscles: LD had higher tenderness (39.28 N vs. 49.77 N, = 0.0011), lower cooking loss (23.56% vs. 27.04%, = 0.0002), and higher thawing loss (12.38% vs. 9.72%, = 0.0021) compared to ST muscle, which had a lighter color (L* = 41.90 vs. 37.73, < 0.0001) and longer sarcomeres (2.22 μm vs. 1.74 μm, < 0.0001). While the TS suspension method significantly increased sarcomere length (2.05 μm vs. 1.92 μm, = 0.0020), it did not lead to significant improvements in other quality attributes such as pH, water-holding capacity, or tenderness. The results indicate that although the TS method affects muscle structure by elongating sarcomeres (with an average difference of 0.13 μm), it does not significantly improve the overall quality of the horsemeat compared to the AT method after 7 days of aging. A combination of factors beyond suspension methods, such as optimizing aging periods or considering additional processing techniques, may therefore be required to improve horsemeat quality. This study provides insights into the specific attributes of LD and ST muscles and their response to suspension methods and contributes to a better understanding of optimizing horsemeat quality for commercial purposes.
本研究通过分析背最长肌(LD)和半腱肌(ST),探究悬吊方法(嫩拉伸法,TS;或跟腱法,AT)是否能提高马肉品质。总共25具马胴体被视为实验单位,并纵向分割,一半使用TS方法悬吊,另一半使用AT方法悬吊,这样可以在同一胴体内进行直接比较。在商业加工条件下熟成7天后,对LD和ST肌肉的pH值、颜色(L*、a*、b*)、保水性(滴水损失、解冻损失、蒸煮损失)、嫩度(沃纳-布拉茨勒剪切力)和肌节长度进行分析。使用SAS中的MIXED程序进行统计分析,并应用邦费罗尼校正进行事后比较。结果发现,不同肌肉之间存在显著差异:与ST肌肉相比,LD肌肉的嫩度更高(39.28 N对49.77 N,P = 0.0011)、蒸煮损失更低(23.56%对27.04%,P = 0.0002)、解冻损失更高(12.38%对9.72%,P = 0.0021),而ST肌肉颜色更浅(L* = 41.90对37.73,P < 0.0001)且肌节更长(2.22μm对1.74μm,P < 0.0001)。虽然TS悬吊方法显著增加了肌节长度(2.05μm对1.92μm,P = 0.0020),但在pH值、保水性或嫩度等其他品质属性方面并未带来显著改善。结果表明,尽管TS方法通过拉长肌节(平均差异为0.13μm)影响肌肉结构,但在熟成7天后,与AT方法相比,它并未显著提高马肉的整体品质。因此,可能需要结合悬吊方法之外的多种因素,如优化熟成时间或考虑其他加工技术,来提高马肉品质。本研究深入了解了LD和ST肌肉的具体属性及其对悬吊方法的反应,有助于更好地理解如何为商业目的优化马肉品质。