Murphy Caleb J, Narala Vanshika, Katiki Aishwarya, Martinez Maylyn S, Cerasale Matthew T, Nguyen Khanh T
Section of Hospital Medicine, University of Chicago Department of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois, USA
Division of Hospital Medicine, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
BMJ Open Qual. 2024 Dec 18;13(4):e002889. doi: 10.1136/bmjoq-2024-002889.
High-frequency recurring orders placed through the electronic medical record (EMR) may contribute to unnecessary care in hospitalised patients. This quality initiative sought to develop and pilot test a hospital order set for bundled review and de-implementation of common recurring orders.
A voluntary-use EMR order set was developed to display low-frequency order alternatives for common hospital care components. The order set was introduced to hospitalists at a large academic hospital from February to June 2023. Orders for overnight vital signs, tubes/tethers (a composite of telemetry, continuous pulse oximetry and Foley catheter) and daily labs (a composite of complete blood counts and metabolic panels) were monitored twice weekly in hospitalised patients at low risk for clinical decompensation from December 2022 through June 2023. Paired t-test was used to assess for differences in order frequency before and after order set introduction.
The order set was used in 48 unique encounters to place 80 de-implementation orders, most commonly for discontinuation of overnight vital signs (n=37). Two or more de-implementation orders were placed during 44% of order set encounters. Mean (SD) total high-frequency orders decreased by 0.22 per patient day (95% CI -0.39 to -0.06; p=0.010) after order set introduction, driven by a reduction in overnight vital sign orders of 0.17 per patient day (95% CI -0.23 to -0.12; p<0.001). There was no statistically significant difference in orders for tubes/tethers or daily labs before and after order set introduction.
Introduction of a novel order set for bundled review and de-implementation of recurring orders was associated with reduced high-frequency recurring orders in hospitalised patients, driven by a reduction in overnight vital signs. Nearly half of order set use was for two or more de-implementation orders, suggesting that bundling de-implementation orders may be an efficient way to reduce unnecessary orders.
通过电子病历(EMR)下达的高频重复医嘱可能导致住院患者接受不必要的治疗。这项质量改进举措旨在制定并试点测试一套医院医嘱集,用于对常见重复医嘱进行汇总审查和停用。
开发了一套自愿使用的电子病历医嘱集,以展示常见医院护理项目的低频医嘱替代方案。2023年2月至6月,该医嘱集被引入一家大型学术医院的住院医师处。从2022年12月至2023年6月,对临床失代偿低风险住院患者的夜间生命体征、管道/束缚装置(遥测、连续脉搏血氧饱和度和弗利导尿管的组合)和每日实验室检查(全血细胞计数和代谢指标组合)医嘱进行每周两次监测。采用配对t检验评估医嘱集引入前后医嘱频率的差异。
该医嘱集在48次独特的诊疗中被用于下达80条停用医嘱,最常见的是停用夜间生命体征(n = 37)。在44%的医嘱集诊疗中下达了两条或更多停用医嘱。医嘱集引入后,每位患者每天的高频医嘱平均(标准差)总数减少了0.22(95%置信区间 -0.39至 -0.06;p = 0.010),主要是由于夜间生命体征医嘱每位患者每天减少了0.17(95%置信区间 -0.23至 -0.12;p < 0.001)。医嘱集引入前后管道/束缚装置或每日实验室检查医嘱无统计学显著差异。
引入一套用于对重复医嘱进行汇总审查和停用的新型医嘱集与住院患者高频重复医嘱减少相关,主要是由于夜间生命体征医嘱减少。近一半的医嘱集使用是用于两条或更多停用医嘱,这表明汇总停用医嘱可能是减少不必要医嘱的有效方式。