Suppr超能文献

掠夺性期刊和论文工厂危及知识管理。

[Predatory journals and paper mills jeopardise knowledge management].

作者信息

Maisonneuve Hervé

机构信息

123, rue Duguesclin, 69006 Lyon, France.

出版信息

Bull Cancer. 2025 Jan;112(1):100-110. doi: 10.1016/j.bulcan.2024.12.002. Epub 2024 Dec 17.

Abstract

With the advent of the author-pays business model replacing subscription, mercantile publishers have created journals. They respond to the dissatisfaction of naive researchers faced with the difficulties of publishing quickly and widely. These publishers favour commercial interests over knowledge and do not respect good publication practices. The network of science academies and UNESCO distinguish three groups of publishers: fraudulent (predatory journals), of poor quality (journals of complacency that are not to be recommended) and of good quality (legitimate journals). Good and bad articles can be found in all journals. Quality journals have created special issues with rapid reviews to remain competitive. The proliferation of these journals is a source of misinformation. Paper mills are commercial scientific writing and communication companies that sell articles to researchers in order to put their name among the authors. There are social networks accounts to promote these articles and sell the authors' positions. Review and citation mills are also scams. Five factors have influenced these abuses: the monetisation of research results; the value of publishing a lot; the shortcomings of peer review; the lack of international certification of scientific journals; and artificial intelligence with its best and worst. The system can continue as long as there are satisfied researchers and institutional leaders do nothing. Fortunately, awareness is growing, but we are all waiting for our neighbours to change their practices.

摘要

随着作者付费商业模式取代订阅模式的出现,商业出版商创办了各类期刊。他们回应了天真的研究人员在快速广泛发表论文方面面临困难时的不满情绪。这些出版商将商业利益置于知识之上,且不尊重良好的出版规范。科学研究院网络和联合国教科文组织区分出三类出版商:欺诈性的(掠夺性期刊)、质量差的(自满型期刊,不推荐)以及质量好的(正规期刊)。所有期刊中都能找到好文章和坏文章。高质量期刊创建了快速评审的特刊以保持竞争力。这些期刊的泛滥是错误信息的一个来源。论文工厂是商业性的科学写作和交流公司,它们向研究人员出售文章,以便让这些研究人员成为作者。还有社交网络账号来推广这些文章并兜售作者身份。评审和引用工厂同样是骗局。有五个因素影响了这些滥用行为:研究成果的货币化;大量发表的价值;同行评审的缺陷;科学期刊缺乏国际认证;以及人工智能带来的利弊。只要有满意的研究人员,而机构领导无所作为,这个体系就会持续下去。幸运的是,人们的意识正在增强,但我们都在等待邻居改变他们的做法。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验