Li Yitong, Hou Bowen, Zhang Yao, Wang Yi, Chu Yongqiang, Li Xiaoming
Department of Radiology, Tongji Hospital, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China.
Quant Imaging Med Surg. 2024 Dec 5;14(12):9323-9334. doi: 10.21037/qims-24-1230. Epub 2024 Nov 29.
Quantitative assessment of cortical bone microstructure is crucial for the evaluation of osteoporosis, yet current clinical methods such as dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) have many limitations. The quantitative assessment without radiation can be achieved by ultrashort echo time (UTE) magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), where double-echo UTE has high clinical feasibility. However, related studies have mainly focused on distal extremities, and there is a lack of studies on the proximal femur. This cross-sectional study, as a preliminary study for quantitative assessment of proximal femoral cortical bone in healthy adults by double-echo UTE MRI, aimed to evaluate the repeatability and explore the impact of potential influencing factors on UTE measurements, thereby providing a reference for the further clinical application of this technique.
Healthy volunteers without osteoporosis risk factors were enrolled and underwent double-echo UTE MRI of the proximal femur. Porosity index (PI) and cortical bone thickness (CbTh) were obtained manually by two radiologists independently on double-echo UTE images using image processing software. Repeatability of PI and CbTh measurements were evaluated using intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) analysis. PI and CbTh of different limbs and sexes were compared, and P<0.05 indicated statistical significance for these analyses. Correlations of PI and CbTh with age and body mass index (BMI) were assessed by Pearson or Spearman correlation coefficient as well as the partial Pearson correlation coefficient. Curve estimation was used to assess non-monotonic variable correlations in scatterplots. For these analyses, P<0.025 indicated statistical significance according to the Bonferroni correction.
A total of 52 healthy cases (33 males, 19 females) aged 22-55 years were included for analysis, where no statistical difference in age was found between sexes (P=0.586) and BMI of males was greater than that of females (P=0.007). The repeatability of PI and CbTh measurements was excellent (ICC 0.985 and 0.943, respectively). The proximal femoral cortical PI was greater on the non-dominant side (P<0.001). PI was greater in males than in females (non-dominant: P<0.001, dominant: P=0.032) and CbTh was greater on the non-dominant side in males than in females (P=0.036) after excluding the effect of confounding factor (BMI). PI on the dominant side was positively correlated with BMI in males (r=0.535, P=0.001), and CbTh on the non-dominant side was positively correlated with BMI in males (r=0.482, P=0.005). There was a U-shaped curve trend between dominant side cortical PI and age in females (y = 65.32 - 1.88x + 0.02x, R=0.348, P=0.033), although there was no statistical significance after Bonferroni correction.
Double-echo UTE MRI enables quantitative assessment of proximal femoral cortical microarchitecture with excellent repeatability. We identified the effects of limb dominance, sex, age, and BMI on UTE measurements in healthy adults, which can serve as a reference for future studies on proximal femoral cortical bone and is essential before clinical application.
皮质骨微结构的定量评估对骨质疏松症的评估至关重要,但目前的临床方法如双能X线吸收法(DXA)存在诸多局限性。通过超短回波时间(UTE)磁共振成像(MRI)可实现无辐射的定量评估,其中双回波UTE具有较高的临床可行性。然而,相关研究主要集中在四肢远端,缺乏对股骨近端的研究。本横断面研究作为通过双回波UTE MRI对健康成年人股骨近端皮质骨进行定量评估的初步研究,旨在评估其重复性并探讨潜在影响因素对UTE测量的影响,从而为该技术的进一步临床应用提供参考。
纳入无骨质疏松风险因素的健康志愿者,对其进行股骨近端的双回波UTE MRI检查。两名放射科医生分别使用图像处理软件在双回波UTE图像上手动获取孔隙率指数(PI)和皮质骨厚度(CbTh)。使用组内相关系数(ICC)分析评估PI和CbTh测量的重复性。比较不同肢体和性别的PI和CbTh,P<0.05表示这些分析具有统计学意义。通过Pearson或Spearman相关系数以及偏Pearson相关系数评估PI和CbTh与年龄和体重指数(BMI)的相关性。曲线估计用于评估散点图中的非单调变量相关性。对于这些分析,根据Bonferroni校正,P<0.025表示具有统计学意义。
共纳入52例年龄在22 - 55岁的健康受试者(男性33例,女性19例)进行分析,其中性别间年龄无统计学差异(P = 0.586),男性BMI大于女性(P = 0.007)。PI和CbTh测量的重复性极佳(ICC分别为0.985和0.943)。非优势侧股骨近端皮质PI更高(P<0.001)。排除混杂因素(BMI)影响后,男性的PI高于女性(非优势侧:P<0.001,优势侧:P = 0.032),男性非优势侧的CbTh大于女性(P = 0.036)。男性优势侧PI与BMI呈正相关(r = 0.535,P = 0.001),男性非优势侧CbTh与BMI呈正相关(r = 0.482,P = 0.005)。女性优势侧皮质PI与年龄之间存在U型曲线趋势(y = 65.32 - 1.88x + 0.02x,R = 0.348,P = 0.033),尽管经Bonferroni校正后无统计学意义。
双回波UTE MRI能够对股骨近端皮质微结构进行定量评估,且重复性极佳。我们确定了肢体优势、性别、年龄和BMI对健康成年人UTE测量的影响,可为未来股骨近端皮质骨研究提供参考,且在临床应用前至关重要。