Mayrhuber Laura, Andres Sebastian D, Legrand Mathilde L, Luft Andreas R, Ryser Franziska, Gassert Roger, Veerbeek Janne M, Duinen Jannie van, Schwarz Anne, Franinovic Karmen, Rickert Christoph, Schkommodau Erik, O Held Jeremia P, Easthope Chris Awai, Lambercy Olivier
Rehabilitation Engineering Laboratory, Department of Health Sciences and Technology, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Vascular Neurology and Neurorehabilitation, Department of Neurology, Hospital of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2024 Dec 21;21(1):220. doi: 10.1186/s12984-024-01527-2.
Upper limb impairment post-stroke often leads to a predominant use of the less affected arm and consequent learned disuse of the affected side, hindering upper limb outcome. Wearable sensors such as accelerometers, combined with smart reminders (i.e., based on the amount of arm activity), offer a potential approach to promote increased use of the affected arm to improve upper limb use during daily life. This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of wrist vibratory reminders during a six-week home-based intervention in chronic stroke survivors.
We evaluated the impact of the home-based intervention on the primary outcome, the Motor Activity Log-14 Item Version scores Amount of Use (MAL-14 AOU), and the secondary outcomes MAL-14 Quality of Movement (QOM) and sensor-derived activity metrics from the affected arm. A randomized controlled trial design was used for the study: the intervention group received personalized reminders based on individualized arm activity goals, while the control group did not receive any feedback. Mixed linear models assessed the influence of the group, week of the intervention period, and initial impairment level on MAL-14 and arm activity metrics.
Forty-two participants were enrolled in the study. Overall, participants exhibited modest but not clinically relevant increases in MAL-14 AOU (+ 0.2 points) and QOM (+ 0.2 points) after the intervention period, with no statistically significant differences between the intervention and control group. Feasibility challenges were noted, such as adherence to wearing the trackers and sensor data quality. However, in participants with sufficiently available sensor data (n = 23), the affected arm use extracted from the sensor data was significantly higher in the intervention group (p < 0.05). The initial impairment level strongly influenced affected arm use and both MAL-14 AOU and QOM (p < 0.01).
The study investigated the effectiveness of incorporating activity trackers with smart reminders to increase affected arm activity among stroke survivors during daily life. While the results regarding the increased arm use at home are promising, patient-reported outcomes remained below clinically meaningful thresholds and showed no group differences. Further, it is essential to acknowledge feasibility issues such as adherence to wearing the trackers during the intervention and missing sensor data.
NCT03294187.
中风后上肢功能障碍常导致患者主要使用患侧上肢较少,进而引发习得性废用,这会阻碍上肢功能的恢复。可穿戴传感器,如加速度计,与智能提醒(即基于手臂活动量)相结合,为促进患侧上肢更多使用以改善日常生活中的上肢功能提供了一种潜在方法。本研究旨在评估为期六周的家庭干预中手腕振动提醒对慢性中风幸存者的疗效。
我们评估了家庭干预对主要结局指标(运动活动日志14项版本的使用量评分,即MAL - 14 AOU)以及次要结局指标MAL - 14运动质量(QOM)和患侧手臂的传感器衍生活动指标的影响。本研究采用随机对照试验设计:干预组基于个体化手臂活动目标接受个性化提醒,而对照组未接受任何反馈。混合线性模型评估了组、干预期周数和初始损伤水平对MAL - 14和手臂活动指标的影响。
42名参与者纳入本研究。总体而言,干预期后参与者的MAL - 14 AOU(增加0.2分)和QOM(增加0.2分)有适度但无临床意义的增加,干预组与对照组之间无统计学显著差异。注意到了可行性挑战,如佩戴追踪器的依从性和传感器数据质量。然而,在传感器数据足够可用的参与者(n = 23)中,干预组从传感器数据中提取的患侧手臂使用情况显著更高(p < 0.05)。初始损伤水平强烈影响患侧手臂使用以及MAL - 14 AOU和QOM(p < 0.01)。
本研究调查了将活动追踪器与智能提醒相结合以增加中风幸存者日常生活中患侧手臂活动的有效性。虽然在家中增加手臂使用的结果很有前景,但患者报告的结局仍低于临床有意义的阈值,且未显示出组间差异。此外,必须认识到可行性问题,如干预期间佩戴追踪器的依从性和传感器数据缺失。
NCT03294187。