D'Alessandro Matthew, Mackie Ryan, Berger Tom, Ott Carl, Sullivan Christopher, Curry Ian
Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2024 Dec;95(12):885-896. doi: 10.3357/AMHP.6489.2024.
Managing cognitive demand is critical for aviation safety. Yet, accurately assessing pilot workload during complex flight maneuvers remains challenging. This study evaluated an integrated methodology combining real-time cognitive engagement indicators to provide a comprehensive assessment and assess the reliability of physiological and subjective measures for monitoring operator state.
Six experienced U.S. Army rotary-wing pilots completed simulated high-workload flight scenarios like low-altitude, reconnaissance, and air threat avoidance maneuvers. Continuous wireless electroencephalography (EEG), heart rate data, and subjective workload ratings were recorded during the flights.
EEG engagement indices and heart rate variability metrics demonstrated reliable within-subject consistency across trials for individual pilots, with mean intraclass correlation coefficient values ranging from 0.59-0.69. Both measures exhibited synchronized fluctuations across pilots at key events, increasing during high workload segments and decreasing in lower demand periods. Subjective ratings also showed good within-subject reliability, with mean intraclass correlation coefficient values ranging from 0.74-0.85. These findings underscore the reliability of our measurements, instilling confidence in the validity of our research.
The findings of this study provide strong support for the feasibility of using a multi-measure approach that integrates EEG, heart rate variability, and subjective ratings. This approach can continuously monitor real-time cognitive workload fluctuations during simulated rotary-wing operations. While objective measures showed within-subject consistency, substantial between-subject variability highlights the importance of individualized neurocognitive profiling. The integration of neurophysiological, autonomic, subjective, and environmental data holds great promise for the future of pilot workload assessment despite the challenges posed by individual differences. D'Alessandro M, Mackie R, Berger T, Ott C, Sullivan C, Curry I. Real-time neurophysiological and subjective indices of cognitive engagement in high-speed flight. Aerosp Med Hum Perform. 2024; 95(12):885-896.
管理认知需求对航空安全至关重要。然而,在复杂飞行操作过程中准确评估飞行员工作量仍然具有挑战性。本研究评估了一种综合方法,该方法结合实时认知参与指标以提供全面评估,并评估用于监测操作员状态的生理和主观测量方法的可靠性。
六名经验丰富的美国陆军旋翼机飞行员完成了模拟的高工作量飞行场景,如低空、侦察和空中威胁规避操作。飞行过程中记录了连续的无线脑电图(EEG)、心率数据和主观工作量评分。
EEG参与指数和心率变异性指标在个体飞行员的各试验中表现出可靠的数据一致性,组内相关系数均值在0.59 - 0.69之间。在关键事件中,这两种测量方法在飞行员之间均呈现同步波动,在高工作量阶段增加,在需求较低阶段减少。主观评分在个体内也显示出良好的可靠性,组内相关系数均值在0.74 - 0.85之间。这些发现强调了我们测量的可靠性,增强了对我们研究有效性的信心。
本研究结果为采用整合EEG、心率变异性和主观评分的多测量方法的可行性提供了有力支持。这种方法可以在模拟旋翼机操作过程中持续监测实时认知工作量波动。虽然客观测量方法显示了个体内的一致性,但个体间的显著差异突出了个性化神经认知剖析的重要性。尽管存在个体差异带来的挑战,但神经生理、自主、主观和环境数据的整合对未来飞行员工作量评估具有巨大潜力。达莱桑德罗M、麦基R、伯杰T、奥特C、沙利文C、库里I。高速飞行中认知参与的实时神经生理和主观指标。航空航天医学与人类表现。2024;95(12):885 - 896。