Sambe Babacar Souleymane, Zobrist Stephanie, Sheahan William, Soni Divya, Diagne Aissatou, Sarr Ibrahima, Diatta Arona Sabene, Mbacke Diaw Serigne Ousmane, Golden Allison, Slater Hannah, Jang Ihn Kyung, Roa Nerie, Pal Sampa, Sarr Fatoumata Diene, Faye Joseph, Vigan-Womas Inès, Dieye Yakou, Cisse Moustapha, Domingo Gonzalo J, Niang Makhtar
Institut Pasteur de Dakar, Dakar, Senegal.
PATH, Seattle, United States.
medRxiv. 2024 Dec 13:2024.12.12.24318945. doi: 10.1101/2024.12.12.24318945.
The emergence of -deleted parasites threatens histidine-rich protein 2 (HRP2)-based malaria rapid diagnostic test (RDT) performance. RDTs targeting () lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) may address current product limitations and improve case management.
To evaluate the performance and usability of three LDH-based RDTs in febrile patients.
A cross-sectional diagnostic accuracy study was conducted in Kédougou, Senegal. Capillary blood was tested using the SD Bioline Ag Pf (#05FK50) and three LDH-based RDTs: BIOCREDIT Malaria Ag Pf (pLDH), BIOCREDIT Pf (pLDH/HRPII), and BIOCREDIT Pf/Pv (pLDH/pLDH) (Rapigen Inc., Republic of Korea). Venous blood was collected to repeat the BIOCREDIT RDTs and conduct microscopy. Frozen venous specimens were tested using a reference PCR assay. A quantitative multiplex malaria antigen assay measured antigen concentration. RDT performance was determined and analyzed as a function of antigen concentration distribution. Usability of the -only BIOCREDIT tests was evaluated using a questionnaire.
154/220 participants (70%) were -positive by PCR. The Pf (pLDH/HRPII) test demonstrated the highest sensitivity at 78% (70.9%-84.5%); specificity was 89% (79.4%-95.6%). All RDTs performed better than microscopy (53% sensitivity). RDTs performed better when compared to antigen concentration over PCR results. Improved sensitivity of the Pf (pLDH/HRPII) test was driven by the HRP2 line. Line intensity correlated with antigen concentration. Predicted sensitivity using the analytical limit of detection (LOD) was comparable to observed sensitivity. RDTs demonstrated acceptable usability.
Both HRP2 and LDH contributed to the sensitivity of the best-performing -RDT. RDT analytical LODs can be used to predict performance in populations with known antigen concentrations.
缺失型寄生虫的出现威胁到基于富含组氨酸蛋白2(HRP2)的疟疾快速诊断检测(RDT)的性能。针对疟原虫乳酸脱氢酶(pLDH)的RDT可能会解决当前产品的局限性并改善病例管理。
评估三种基于pLDH的RDT在发热患者中的性能和可用性。
在塞内加尔的凯杜古进行了一项横断面诊断准确性研究。使用SD Bioline Ag Pf(#05FK50)和三种基于pLDH的RDT检测毛细血管血:BIOCREDIT疟疾Ag Pf(pLDH)、BIOCREDIT Pf(pLDH/HRPII)和BIOCREDIT Pf/Pv(pLDH/pLDH)(韩国Rapigen公司)。采集静脉血以重复进行BIOCREDIT RDT检测并进行显微镜检查。使用参考PCR检测法检测冷冻静脉标本。定量多重疟疾抗原检测法测量抗原浓度。根据抗原浓度分布确定并分析RDT的性能。使用问卷评估仅针对疟原虫的BIOCREDIT检测的可用性。
154/220名参与者(70%)通过PCR检测为疟原虫阳性。Pf(pLDH/HRPII)检测的灵敏度最高,为78%(70.9%-84.5%);特异性为89%(79.4%-95.6%)。所有RDT的表现均优于显微镜检查(灵敏度为53%)。与基于PCR结果的抗原浓度相比,RDT表现更好。Pf(pLDH/HRPII)检测灵敏度的提高是由HRP2条带驱动的。条带强度与抗原浓度相关。使用分析检测限(LOD)预测的灵敏度与观察到的灵敏度相当。RDT显示出可接受的可用性。
HRP2和pLDH均有助于表现最佳的疟原虫RDT的灵敏度。RDT分析LOD可用于预测已知抗原浓度人群中的性能。