Agyemang Eric, Ofori-Dua Kwadwo, Dwumah Peter, Forkuor John Boulard
Department of Sociology and Social Work, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, Kumasi, Ghana.
PLoS One. 2024 Dec 23;19(12):e0312527. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0312527. eCollection 2024.
Abundant wood waste is generated globally, but the literature lacks a framework distinguishing sustainable versus unsustainable reuse practices. This gap hinders policy makers and stakeholders from effectively supporting responsible resource utilization. As such, this scoping review aimed to address this gap by evaluating wood waste reuse practices through ecological, financial, and social sustainability lenses. A comprehensive database search yielded 1,150 records, narrowed to 106 included studies through eligibility screening. Data on study details and sustainability factors was extracted without a formal quality appraisal. The protocol ensures a rigorous evidence-mapping approach. The findings revealed that sustainable uses included renewable energy, adsorbents, construction materials, and composting applications. However, toxic preservatives, uncontrolled emissions from burning, intensive harvesting impacts, and contamination risks from uncontrolled mulching perpetuate ecological, social, and financial challenges. Preventing contamination and managing sustainability trade-offs are key priorities. Research innovations, stringent quality control, and supportive policies are imperative to distinguish practices aligned with sustainability principles from those inadvertently causing harm. This review provides a comprehensive framework for making informed decisions to progress wood waste systems toward responsible resource utilization.
全球产生了大量的木材废料,但文献中缺乏一个区分可持续与不可持续再利用做法的框架。这一差距阻碍了政策制定者和利益相关者有效支持负责任的资源利用。因此,本范围综述旨在通过从生态、经济和社会可持续性角度评估木材废料再利用做法来填补这一差距。全面的数据库搜索产生了1150条记录,通过资格筛选后缩小到106项纳入研究。在没有进行正式质量评估的情况下提取了关于研究细节和可持续性因素的数据。该方案确保了一种严格的证据映射方法。研究结果表明,可持续用途包括可再生能源、吸附剂、建筑材料和堆肥应用。然而,有毒防腐剂、燃烧产生的无控制排放、密集采伐影响以及无控制覆盖造成的污染风险,持续存在生态、社会和经济挑战。防止污染和管理可持续性权衡是关键优先事项。研究创新、严格的质量控制和支持性政策对于区分符合可持续性原则的做法与那些无意中造成危害的做法至关重要。本综述为做出明智决策提供了一个全面框架,以推动木材废料系统朝着负责任的资源利用方向发展。