Wainwright Jodi Emma, Cook Erica Jane, Ali Nasreen, Wilkinson Emma, Randhawa Gurch
Institute for Health Research, University of Bedfordshire, Luton, UK.
BMC Public Health. 2024 Dec 23;24(1):3566. doi: 10.1186/s12889-024-21127-y.
Inequalities in cancer, palliative, and end-of-life care services remain a significant challenge, particularly for ethnic minorities who face systemic barriers such as limited awareness, cultural stigmas, and language differences. These disparities hinder equitable access to essential services and contribute to poorer health outcomes for affected communities. Addressing these challenges requires targeted, culturally sensitive initiatives that promote both awareness and uptake of care. Community readiness is a critical factor in the success of such interventions, as it reflects the willingness and capacity of a community to engage with and support change.
A mixed-methods approach was used, combining individual interviews and two focus groups with key informants (N = 14). This study, conducted in the ethnically and geographically diverse region of Bedfordshire, Luton, and Milton Keynes in southeast England, aimed to assess community readiness to embrace initiatives designed to reduce health inequalities in cancer, palliative, and end-of-life care. The key informants, including faith leaders and professional stakeholders, rated community readiness on five anchored scales: Knowledge of efforts, Leadership, Knowledge of the issue, Community Climate, and Resources. The focus groups facilitated a discussion of the ratings, providing deeper insights into community dynamics and barriers.
Overall, the community was identified as being at the pre-planning stage of readiness to address disparities in cancer, palliative, and end-of-life care for ethnic minorities. Quantitatively, faith and religious leaders assessed readiness at the vague awareness stage (mean: 3.88), while professional stakeholders rated it at the pre-planning stage (mean: 4.87). Qualitative findings highlighted limited community knowledge, passive leadership with potential for 'community champions' to foster openness, a positive climate influenced by younger generations, widespread misconceptions, language barriers, and resource constraints affecting service accessibility.
The Community Readiness Model provides an insight into the community's position regarding disparities in access to cancer, palliative and end-of-life services. In order to ensure that continuing efforts are successful in addressing existing inequalities rather than exacerbating them, this study emphasises how critical it is to evaluate the readiness of the community in order to avoid widening inequalities in access and use of services.
癌症、姑息治疗和临终关怀服务方面的不平等仍然是一项重大挑战,尤其是对于面临诸如认知有限、文化耻辱感和语言差异等系统性障碍的少数族裔而言。这些差异阻碍了公平获得基本服务的机会,并导致受影响社区的健康结果更差。应对这些挑战需要有针对性的、对文化敏感的举措,以提高对护理的认知并促进其接受度。社区准备情况是此类干预措施成功的关键因素,因为它反映了社区参与并支持变革的意愿和能力。
采用了混合方法,将个人访谈与两个关键信息提供者焦点小组(N = 14)相结合。这项研究在英格兰东南部贝德福德郡、卢顿和米尔顿凯恩斯种族和地理多样的地区进行,旨在评估社区对旨在减少癌症、姑息治疗和临终关怀方面健康不平等的举措的准备情况。关键信息提供者包括宗教领袖和专业利益相关者,他们在五个锚定量表上对社区准备情况进行评分:对努力的了解、领导力、对问题的了解、社区氛围和资源。焦点小组促进了对评分的讨论,提供了对社区动态和障碍的更深入见解。
总体而言,该社区被确定处于为解决少数族裔在癌症、姑息治疗和临终关怀方面的差异而准备的规划前阶段。从数量上看,宗教领袖将准备情况评估为模糊认知阶段(平均:3.88),而专业利益相关者将其评为规划前阶段(平均:4.87)。定性研究结果突出了社区知识有限、被动的领导力以及“社区倡导者”促进开放的潜力、受年轻一代影响的积极氛围、普遍存在的误解、语言障碍以及影响服务可及性的资源限制。
社区准备情况模型提供了对社区在获得癌症、姑息治疗和临终关怀服务方面差异的立场的洞察。为了确保持续的努力能够成功解决现有不平等问题而不是加剧这些问题,本研究强调评估社区准备情况以避免扩大服务获取和使用方面的不平等是多么关键。