Upadhyay Kuldip, Viramgami Ankit, Bagepally Bhavani Shankara, Balachandar Rakesh
ICMR - National Institute of Occupational Health, Ahmedabad, India.
ICMR - National Institute of Epidemiology, Chennai, India.
Toxicol Rep. 2024 Nov 29;13:101837. doi: 10.1016/j.toxrep.2024.101837. eCollection 2024 Dec.
In view of inconsistent reports on the association between chronic lead (Pb) exposure and renal injury markers (potential site of injury), the present systematic review explored their association by reviewing studies that investigated chronic Pb-exposed and those without obvious Pb exposure. Studies reporting blood Pb levels(BLL) and biomarkers of kidney injury [i.e. N-acetyl-β-D-glucosaminidase (NAG), Micro-Globulin(μG) and others] among chronic Pb-exposed and unexposed individuals were systematically searched from digital databases available until February 26, 2024. Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis Guidelines were adhered to during the execution. Pooled effect size and heterogeneity were estimated using the random effect model and Studies reporting blood Pb levels(BLL) and biomarkers of kidney injury [i.e. N-acetyl-β-D-glucosaminidase (NAG), Micro-Globulin(μG) and others] among chronic Pb-exposed and unexposed individuals were systematically searched from digital databases available until February 26, 2024. Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis Guidelines were adhered to during the execution. Pooled effect size and heterogeneity were estimated using the random effect model and . Pooled quantitative analysis revealed elevated BLL [25.64 (21.59-29.70) µg/dL] Pb-exposed group. The pooled analysis confirmed significantly higher urinary NAG [0.68(0.26-1.10) units], α1μG [3.82(0.96-6.68) mg/g creatinine] βμG [1.5(0.86-2.14) units and serum creatinine [0.03(0.00-0.05) mg/dL] levels in Pb-exposed group, with high heterogeneity. Current observations indicate the proximal tubular injury as the early and potential site of Pb-induced renal injury. Pb-exposed individuals experience proximal tubular injury (KIM-1, NAG) and dysfunction (β2μG, α1μG, Cystatin-C) prior to obvious clinical renal failure. Present observations should caution the policymakers towards drafting regulations for periodic screening with markers of renal injury and / or dysfunction among those chronically exposed to lead despite the certainty of evidence is very low.
鉴于关于慢性铅(Pb)暴露与肾损伤标志物(潜在损伤部位)之间关联的报告不一致,本系统评价通过回顾调查慢性铅暴露者和无明显铅暴露者的研究来探讨它们之间的关联。从截至2024年2月26日可用的数字数据库中系统检索了报告慢性铅暴露者和未暴露者血铅水平(BLL)及肾损伤生物标志物[即N - 乙酰 - β - D - 氨基葡萄糖苷酶(NAG)、微球蛋白(μG)等]的研究。在执行过程中遵循系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目指南。使用随机效应模型估计合并效应量和异质性。合并定量分析显示铅暴露组的血铅水平升高[25.64(21.59 - 29.70)μg/dL]。合并分析证实铅暴露组的尿NAG[0.68(0.26 - 1.10)单位]、α1μG[3.82(0.96 - 6.68)mg/g肌酐]、βμG[1.5(0.86 - 2.14)单位]和血清肌酐[0.03(0.00 - 0.05)mg/dL]水平显著更高,异质性较高。当前观察结果表明近端肾小管损伤是铅诱导肾损伤的早期潜在部位。在明显的临床肾衰竭之前,铅暴露个体就经历近端肾小管损伤(KIM - 1、NAG)和功能障碍(β2μG、α1μG、胱抑素 - C)。尽管证据确定性很低,但当前观察结果应提醒政策制定者为那些长期接触铅的人群制定定期进行肾损伤和/或功能障碍标志物筛查的法规。