Lam Janeme, El Nsouli Dayana, Lee E Lyn, Alqeisi Tawfiq, Kane Ros, McGonagle Ian, Laparidou Despina, Nelson David, Armani Keivan
Department of Pharmacy, Northampton General Hospital NHS Trust, Northampton, UK.
Department of Pharmacy, University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust, Derby, UK.
BMJ Open. 2024 Dec 23;14(12):e093636. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-093636.
We sought to review studies that examine healthcare professionals' and students' knowledge, attitudes and practices (KAP) regarding medication disposal. We also explore recommendations and barriers related to appropriate medication disposal.
A systematic review was conducted that adhered to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses.
MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, Web of Science, PsycINFO and Google Scholar were searched up to 23 February 2024.
Qualitative, quantitative and mixed-method primary research studies. There was no limitation on the publication date, geographical locations or the study settings.
Pharmacists, doctors, nurses and students from these respective professional groups in any country.
The levels of healthcare staff and students' KAPs about disposal of unwanted medications.
Data extraction was conducted by four of the researchers independently. The study details were categorised into three main domains, that is, KAP using the KAP model. Other relevant information was also extracted, and synthesised in overall themes, such as challenges and recommendations.
Thirty-seven studies from 18 countries (Asia n=21, the USA n=7, Africa n=5, EU n=2, South America n=2) were included. 86.5% (n=32) investigated participants' knowledge of medication disposal. Although there was a good level of awareness about the environmental impacts, there were significant gaps in knowledge regarding correct disposal methods, available services, guidelines and training. Thirty studies explored participants' attitudes towards medication disposal. There was a generally positive attitude towards the need for environmentally safe disposal practices. Thirty-five studies evaluated participants' practices in relation to medication disposal. Although there was generally a positive attitude and some understanding of appropriate disposal methods, the majority of the participants did not follow the practice guidelines, especially outside healthcare settings.
Although healthcare staff and students have fair knowledge and positive attitudes towards medicine disposal, their actual practices are lacking. One significant challenge identified is the limited awareness about proper disposal methods coupled with a lack of established services or guidelines. Even in cases where take-back programmes are available, they often face issues with accessibility. To tackle these challenges, it is suggested that governmental bodies should establish and enforce clear policies on medication disposal while also expanding educational initiatives to increase understanding among professionals and students. Furthermore, improving access to take-back programmes is crucial for ensuring safe medication disposal and minimising potential environmental and health hazards.
CRD42024503162.
我们试图回顾那些研究医疗保健专业人员和学生关于药物处置的知识、态度和实践(KAP)的研究。我们还探讨与适当药物处置相关的建议和障碍。
进行了一项系统综述,该综述遵循系统综述和Meta分析的首选报告项目。
截至2024年2月23日,对MEDLINE、Embase、CINAHL、科学网、PsycINFO和谷歌学术进行了检索。
定性、定量和混合方法的原发性研究。对出版日期、地理位置或研究背景没有限制。
来自任何国家的这些各自专业组的药剂师、医生、护士和学生。
医护人员和学生关于处置不需要药物的KAP水平。
由四名研究人员独立进行数据提取。研究细节被分为三个主要领域,即使用KAP模型的KAP。还提取了其他相关信息,并综合为总体主题,如挑战和建议。
纳入了来自18个国家的37项研究(亚洲21项,美国7项,非洲5项,欧盟2项,南美洲2项)。86.5%(n = 32)的研究调查了参与者对药物处置的知识。尽管对环境影响有较高的认识水平,但在正确处置方法、可用服务、指南和培训方面的知识存在显著差距。30项研究探讨了参与者对药物处置的态度。对环境安全处置做法的必要性普遍持积极态度。35项研究评估了参与者与药物处置相关的实践。尽管总体上态度积极且对适当处置方法有一定理解,但大多数参与者未遵循实践指南,尤其是在医疗保健环境之外。
尽管医护人员和学生对药物处置有一定的知识和积极态度,但他们的实际做法存在不足。确定的一个重大挑战是对适当处置方法的认识有限,同时缺乏既定的服务或指南。即使在有回收计划的情况下,它们也常常面临可达性问题。为应对这些挑战,建议政府机构应制定并执行关于药物处置的明确政策,同时扩大教育举措以提高专业人员和学生的认识。此外,改善回收计划的可达性对于确保安全的药物处置以及最大限度减少潜在的环境和健康危害至关重要。
PROSPERO注册号:CRD42024503162。